Whos better ? Jermain Taylor or Joe Clazaghe

Based on resume as it has been said it has to be Jermain Taylor.

Head to head is a 50/50 fight in which I would favour Taylor because he is the younger fighter.

 

So being a rational human being, you agree Calzaghe is the "better" of the two mate?

 

Taylor has sort out far better fighters then Calzaghe though. Fighting guys like Rick Thornberry is a dead set embarrassment in your 4th title defense.

 

Video footage, common sense, the margin of the victories on his resume.

 

who would win probably Calazaghe, but Taylor has the better resume for sure and is alot younger. In 2 more years I think Taylor would beat him though.

 

You think Calzaghe would lose to Ouma?

 

Is this a serious question?:huh

 

you agree Winky/Calazaghe ends in a close decision, Winky never gets blown out and I believe hes the better boxer out of the two of them.

 

I have to go with JC on this one

 

Not, it was obvious all along a fighter with a right hand like Tszyu's would beat an erratic southpaw.

It is very easy when you consider how a tiny southpaw in Ouma was able to pressure Taylor. Now imagine Ouma was 6 foot taller, stronger, faster, more skilled and you see Taylor losing.

 

How will Taylor beat Calzaghe?

With his devastating power?

His tremendous workrate?

His brilliance vs southpaws?

 

And Soliman?

 

Nope

Joe beats Jermain Taylor UD

 

Jc

 

I hate how alot of Calzaghe fans act like no one can beat him. Im reading alot of "Jermain Taylor has no chance" or "JC hands down." Why people are so obsessed with Calzaghe i have no idea. To say that Calzaghe will win is one thing. To say he would udderly dominate a champion on JTs level is just foolish. I hate it when the idol worship of a boxer based on where he is from or whatever reason clouds peoples reasoning.