Who's got the better resume: Donaire or Martinez

I give the edge to Donaire, but it's fairly close.

 

Mthalane has become a very good 112 titlist.

Hernan Marquez has become a very, very good 112 titlist.

Sidorenko was a long time 118 lb titlist. I don't think anyone would accuse him of being irrelevant.

Raul Martinez was undefeated when Nonito took him out impressively and is nothing to scoff at. Martinez is a better win than anything Sergio has Williams, Pavlik, and Dzinziruk aside.

---

Two can play at that game, buddy.

Williams BEAT Sergio before Sergio won in the re-match. However, that doesn't even mean much as Williams turned around and looked like garbage against Lara.

Dzinziruk had never fought at middleweight before, and hasn't fought at all in the year since.

Pavlik has fought once since their fight of nearly two years ago, looking like garbage against a guy who should be considered a journeyman at best.

Cintron, after the draw/loss to Sergio, went on to lose to Carlos Molina and Saul Alvarez by decisive beatings.

How can you defend that resume after insulting Donaire's in the manner which you did?!? And after that, there is what, Saul Roman, Darren Barker, then Adrian Stone?

 

Was actually surprised to see many people goin for Donaire.

 

If this isn't a joke it's just an insane statement to make, mate.

 

Darchinyan and Montiel over Pavlik