Whos greater Mayweather or Whittaker?

Still Whitaker. Mayweather is catching up though.

 

Mayweather is a better fighter than Whitaker ever was.

 

Still whitaker for me, as others have said i don't think its an unreasonable discussion (i never really have) but i've got to still give pea the nod here. If floyd beats pacquaio come back to me on that though as it may have changed

 

I think Floyd definitely better by a small margin

 

Pea Whitaker

 

Pea by a mile....Look what a past his prime Pea did to De Laa
hoya and compare it to Mayweathers performance.

 

Mayweather is closing in very, very fast.

 

for right now its still whittaker but floyd is closing the gap though, i think its sweet pea's performance against chavez that sets him apart from floyds resume,but if floyd fights and beats pacman then i can safely say floyd has surpassed sweet pea.

 

At 154, too.

I went for 'even', but that's shorthand for "It's close enough that I can see reasons to swing it either way". If Floyd has one or two more fights of the magnitude of last night (boxing, not publicity), then it definitely tips Floyd's way, IMO.

 

Ditto.

 

I have Pernell in my top 5 ATG.