Who's greater PFP, Floyd Mayweather or Jersey Joe Walcott.

Why are we trying to compare someone who was a HW to little Floyd. I hate Floyd but jeez is this really pushing the envelope.

 

Jersey has a better resume

 

Yes but thats was also due to the fact that he began to cherry pick his fights at WW.

 

I thought you said it was a testament to Walcott having a bad game plan?

 

He was on the tail end preparing to retire, and was already an all-timer before reaching Welterweight.

 

Nah....Marciano is more impressive for having KTFO wins over both Charles, Louis, and Walcott, Moore....Dont 4get the indominable Cockell.

 

An alltimer but low on that poll for sure.

 

but i feel PBF has a better overall ability..thus how would you weigh in ability vs resume?

i say 40% ability, 60% accomplishment

 

Not really. Greatest 130lber of all time.