Who's legacy is greater ODLH or PBF?

deal:deal

 

Bam. Thats one thing I will always give Floyd. He make himself the man at lightweight. I trutly believe the Floyd that fought Corrales is unbeatable.

Oscar always lost his big fights and never established himself due to the middleweight tourney.

Regardless of that Oscar fought Tito, B.Hop, Vargas, Quartey, JCC and Whittaker. Those fights alone give him the upper hand.

Its Floyd's fault. He should have fought all the top welterweights when the WW were the best division in boxing. Instead who does he fight? Baldomir, Zab, Hatton, JMM, and Mosley. Come on man. After that he pissed on his own legacy. At least Oscar fought the best all thoughout his career. Flyod stop being fighter after his win against DLH.

 

First of all JCC and Whitker? Really?


Second of all, fighting and losing does not make you a great fighter. Fighting and winning does. Nobody has a resume off fights you've lost.

 

Ok you're just focusing on one thing.

Its Floyd's fault. He should have fought all the top welterweights when the WW were the best division in boxing. Instead who does he fight? Baldomir, Zab, Hatton, JMM, and Mosley. Come on man. After that he pissed on his own legacy. At least Oscar fought the best all thoughout his career. Flyod stop being fighter after his win against DLH.


What do you say to that? You can't deny that. If you do I'm done discussing this bs anyways. ****! I haven't had a Floyd discussion in forever. How did I get dragged into this maddness!!!!!!!

 

You havent made one decent point. First all you claim all Floyd fans think Floyd is the Goat. Nonsense.

Secondly you keep talking about who they fought which doesnt matter when it comes to legacy. ITS WHO YOU BEAT.

Floyd has beaten as good if not better fighters then Oscar has.


Period.

 

This is what Floyd fans do.

Again I ask you. Do you or do you not agree that Flyod pissed his own legacy after he decided to NOT fight the top WWs? Answer the ****ing question homo.

 

First off again its not who you fight, its who you beat. The discussion isnt about whether Floyds legacy could be better its whether or not it is better the Oscars. You are changing the subject.

Secondly, the only fighter at welter I think was good as advertized is Paul Williams, and now Pacquiao. Mosley and DLH are better fighters then Margarito and Cotto, who I think were Top Rank hype jobs.

So to answer your question could Floyds resume be better, yes. Could it be substantially better? No.

 

Im done. You Flyod fans are crazy.

The Mosley/DLH that Flyod fought are better fighters that Cotto/Margo???? Didn't Cotto beat Mosley? Yeah I think he did.

Whatever it is your smoking...please share. This kush I have is obviously not strong enough.

Next..you're telling me that if Floyd would have been a real ****ing fighter and fought the top WW of his time his record wouldn't have been alot better?? **** if he did I would easily have him over DLH.

Paul Williams
Miguel Cotto
Antonio Margarito
Joshua Clottey
Kermit Cintron
Zab Judah
Carlos Baldomir

**** I can't think of any other top WW a few years back, but regardless. Of that list this man only fight with a REAL welterweight is Carlos ****ing Baldomir.

You're telling me if he would have beaten Margo, Cotto, Cintron, Clottey and/or Williams his legacy would be questioned as much as it is now?

Suck Floyd's dick already.

 

Genaro Hernandez
Angel Manfredy
Carlos Genera
Gregario Vargas
Diego Corrales
Carlos Hernandez
Jesus Chavez
Jose Luis Castillo X2
Demarcus Corley
Arturo Gatti - Gatti...B class fighter

PBF starts getting paid PPV money
Moves to WW

Sharmba Mitchell...WHO??
Zab Judah - Won't knock this fight, but Zab is a true 140 lber
Carlos Baldomir - C class fighter
Oscar De La Hoya - Dead man
Ricky Hatton - A 140 lber
Juan Manuel Marquez - Isn't JMM a lightweight?
Shane Mosley - More faded than my Dominican ***** screwing Grandad

 

its funny how Oscar gets praised for fighting the best and losing in a good effort, but everybody on here calls zab judah a bumb for the exact same reason.lol the level of hate people have for Floyd is ridiculous! The'll do anything to discredit him .even blatantly contradict themselves! Floyds 41-0, beaten 17 world champions , 6 tittles in 6 divisions,(7 if u count the Moseley fight) never been knocked down,not to mention he beat Oscars ass easy! U might as well say zab's legacy is better than Floyd,based on your reasoning and interpretation of accomplishments

And he's still p4p #1. and has been since 2004

 

Say something about this:

Genaro Hernandez
Angel Manfredy
Carlos Genera
Gregario Vargas
Diego Corrales
Carlos Hernandez
Jesus Chavez
Jose Luis Castillo X2
Demarcus Corley
Arturo Gatti - Gatti...B class fighter

PBF starts getting paid PPV money
Moves to WW

Sharmba Mitchell...WHO??
Zab Judah - Won't knock this fight, but Zab is a true 140 lber
Carlos Baldomir - C class fighter
Oscar De La Hoya - Dead man
Ricky Hatton - A 140 lber
Juan Manuel Marquez - Isn't JMM a lightweight?
Shane Mosley - More faded than my Dominican ***** screwing Grandad



To go from fighting the best in one division to fighting lesser division fighters and shot fighters. THAT is PBF's legacy bisides ****ing Chilli, beating up women and security guards.

I love Zab. At least the man comes to fight and fights whoever. Floyd isn't a fighter this man just comes to get paid.

 

Bitches

 

Sharmba Mitchell. Former world champ


Zab is a true 140lber? Floyd is a true 130lber. Same would imply with Hatton. Both weighed more then Floyd on fight night.


Carlos Baldomir. Number 1 welterweight in the world.


Oscar De La Hoya. Koed Ricardo Mayorga before this fight. Same Mayorga that gave Mosley a tough out before he brutalized Margarito. Maywather also fought Oscar at his natural weight class. His 5th weight class btw.


Shane Mosley. Faded? Maybe. Still the best welterweight in the world at the time. For sure.


Btw, 3 of the last 4 fighters floyd has beaten have been ranked in the top 10 P4P.

 

The names Floyd didn't fight, who were atop their divisions when he was, compared to who he DID FIGHT instead, tells it all.

Floyd lost his heart and fire after Castillo. :deal