Who's more deserving in being in the P4P top 10? Cotto or Williams??

I'd go with Williams but I just can't get excited over him, just like Winky. However, I am excited about Saturday night.

 

Cotto

 

Williams of course.. Cotto?? ummm not quite yet buddy.

 

Cotto. If Williams was still at 147 i'd say Williams but I think his chin, height and reach advantage is not as big anymore now that he's at 160.

 

RIGHT NOW!

williams...

to me the p4p top 10 is just a list of the hottest top 10 fighters in boxing at the time....


right now paul williams is doing more impressive stuff ... AT THIS TIME!

but if cotto takes out clottey they should basically be next to each other....but if paul beats winky paul should be higher...

 

Both are deserving.

 

I'd say Cotto b/c his win over mosley is bigger than any of williams wins.

 

Agreed

 

both of them are. remove caballero and calderon then put both of them in.

 

Both deserve it in their own way, but Cotto is far more proven. It has to be Cotto

 

Williams resume sucks. Old Sharmba Mitchell, old Verno Phillips (this one doesn't matter much because Verno was never really good to begin with), and a bunch of no-namers. His best wins are Quintana and Margo and that ain't saying much. Winky will be the best fighter he's ever been in with and the guy is coming off a 2-year layoff. I can't blame Williams for this, but, his resume is what it is. Cotto's is better.