Who's resume is most impressive Trinidad or Mayweather?

Damn, almost 40 fights and an over-the-hill ATG is his biggest win, interesting:think

 

Include Forrest in this list.

 

Is Mayweather's Rec. Impressive? The "climax" Of His Resume Is An Uninpressive Split-dec. Win Against An Older, Past His Prime Odh. Not Impressive At All..

 

A 30 year old Floyd beating a 34 year old Oscar is not impressive even though it was Floyds 5th weight class and was a master boxing exhibition as many analysts referred to it? :rofl

Anyways, wins over division kings like Hernandez, Corrales, Castillo and p4p number 8 Hatton isnt impressive. Gee, I would like to see what it takes for a fighters record to be impressive to you.

 

Trinidads by a mile

 

The same is about Tito's, unless you include losses. Which don't count as Tito loost each time BADLY.

Tito fans also constantly ridicule me pumpimg up his resume with no ones and oldies then asking: who Floyd won? Old Oscar? Tito fought even older RJJ and still managed to loose.

So Trinindad's resume is:
* absolutely embarassing losses
* gift with Oscar
* bunch of nobodies (Carr, Campas, Tiam etc.)
* old Camacho and Whitaker
* couple of good fighters (Mayorga and Vargas)

No way PBF worse than Tito.

 

The climax of the Tito resume is destructive loss to an Older Underdog Hopkins.

 

Trinidad, but I think its because his time was stacked with greater fighters. Mayweather does himself a disservice now by entering the welterweight division at a time when it is close but not yet close enough to the talent of the division of the mid to late nineties and not taking advantage of it. Much like DLH who had an amazing record at other divisions, you will tend to be judged by the last division you fought in.

 

Trinidad. Mayweather has never fought or beat a true A-level elite in their prime.

 

Tito fought, but never beat. In fact, he was exposed.

 

Winky, Hopkins absolutely embarassing losses which DO tell about Tito's greatness more than wins. But they certainly do not add greatness

Add Floyd Manfredy and another Hernandez if you show Carr and Tiam as accomplishments...

Revised:

Trinidad: Camacho, Campas, Carr, Whitaker, DLH, Reid, Thiam, Vargas, Joppy, Mayorga

Mayweather: G.Hernandez, Manfredy, Corrales, C.Hernandez, Chavez, Castillo, Sosa, N'dou, Corley, Gatti, Judah, Baldomir, DLH, Hatton

Remember that Camacho and Whitaker were absolutely shot at that time. DLH was able at least to win Mayorga before fighting PBF.

PBF by a mile.

 

I would say Tito but its not that much better than Floyds. What puts Tito resume over Floyd for me is that he beat fighters when they were undeafeated for the most part like Carr,Campas,ReidVargas and DLH(controvertial)
and knocked out fighters who never been ko before like Joppy,Mayorga,Thiam.