I cant believe the voting of this is so close. For me its simple Pacman. If Joe wants to be ahead of Pacman he needs to beat Pavlik in my opinion aswell as Taylor. But hey i think Joe took advantage of the fact that Hopkins is old enough to claim a Pension.
Just feel Taylor is better than fighting a old Hopkins. Taylor beat Hopkins twice and the talk about Taylor vs Calzaghe went on for how long. I feel this fight should still happen. They talked about on here for two strait years. Why beat a 43 year old Hopkins when you can beat a Prime Talyor. But hey i always thought that Calzaghe was mis handled as was Hatton until Hatton left Warren. Then thats when Hatton started to take chances. and get the big fights. Not taking anything away from Joe at all. I feel he would beat Taylor but as Pavlik gets better and better im not to sure he would beat Kelly now in his Prime as Joe is getting older. Just feel Manny has fought the better guys and he did it at how many weights and now he is stepping up again. If Joe really wants the number #2 or 1 P4P he needs to take on Pavlik and guys that are big names and still in there Prime.
Hatton may be fighting pac aswell so if hatton has a good day in that fight justice will be done and hatton will go above calzaghe
If Joe was American the only thing we would be discussing is who is P4P 1 and 2, Floyd or Joe. Damned haters......
pac, its ridiculous how people think lacy or kessler or even a 43 yr old hopkins equates to MAB, morales, and jmm being undefeated doesn't mean you're better, heck valero is undefeated:nut
does that mean if calzaghe beat mayweather he'd be P4P #1 regardless of the huge difference in weight classes?