whose RESUME is better Manny Pacquiao or Floyd Mayweather Jr.?

:good

 

poochiao's

 

You didn't use the word SHOT when describing EM & MB, never mentioned PEDs, and didn't describe Shane as "slightly past prime".

*****s will be deeply confused and angered. Your post may cost the lives of many kittens.

 

The Fighter of the Decade has the better resume. He got that title for a reason.

 

Plain to see if you are educated and not just a following fanboy of an undefeated (on paper) fighter who feeds on lightweights and pensioners.

Incredible thread

 

Pacquaio's resume is overrated

 

Pacquiao. I can't even envisage a decent argument for anyone saying Floyd. Pac has beaten two HOF fighters who were in their prime and at a good weight for them (Barrera & Marquez). Floyd has never beaten even one HOF fighter in their prime at a good weight for them. Pac's res is deeper too, he has had more good wins over strong opponents. Floyd fought a load of **** 2003-2006. It's Pac hands down.

 

Judah was a great win, at the time he was still one of the most dangerous WWs
Mosley "looked every bit 38" because Floyd made him look that way
Pacquiao DOES NOT get less credit for fighting Barrera and Morales, but all of his fights with Morales (one in which he LOST) Morales was past his prime in every one. And MAB was clearly past it in the rematch, and that was a fight that made everyone think Pac may be on the downslide.
Pacquiao arguably lost both fights to JMM

 

:rofl:rofl:rofl
PAC by wide margin that is why he is seven div champ

 

This content is protected

Pac's first 34 fights he went 32-2 against nobodies across Asia and was knocked out twice by D Class fighters:-(.

This content is protected

Barrera was a great win the first time,possibly his best win, the 2nd fight MAB was past his prime .

This content is protected

He was clearly outboxed by Eric Morales in their first match and then beat EM 2 times when Morales was washed up and beaten up by Zahir Raheem. Actually....Wasssup with Pac fighting Morales coming off of losses? The 1st fight with Morales, Morales was coming off a loss in an epic, brutal fight with Barrera. The 2nd fight with Morales, Morales was coming off being dominated by Zahir Raheem. The 3rd fight, Morales was coming off a loss to Pacquiao.

This content is protected

He had a draw with Marquez and won the 2nd fight which many thought he lost. He was clearly out boxed and out landed Pac in both fights.

David Diaz win? for a BS title that David Diaz won in a vacant title match vs Eric Morales. Marquez stepped up to LW and and beat the REAL champs @ 135 Diaz & Casamayor.

This content is protected

We all know the last time that Oscar De La Hoya weighed 145lbs in a fight was vs Julio Cesar Chavez in 1998. :yikes Yes Manny beat a bigger guy, but he wasnt a LIVE bigger guy.

This content is protected

Floyd Knocked out Hatton first when Hatton was undefeated and ranked P4P#5 in the world.......and I love when people say Hatton weighing in @145 lbs wasnt at Hattons weight to diminish the win. I give Pac credit for the awesome knock out but that wasnt the same Hatton that Mayweather fought.

This content is protected

​

Cotto was a decent catchweight win. Maybe Mannys 2nd best win. Cotto looked like a wounded duck vs Clottey and Roach pounced. Clottey was coming off a loss to Cotto and didnt even come to fight.
​

This content is protected

​

 

tell me why?

 

that should explain

 

Manny Pacquiao.

\ closed thread.

 

Mayweathers for me, i think pacquaios fights gainst DLH and Hatton were meaningless compared to Mayweathers. yes pacquiao had many great wins against in lower classes like JMM and MAB bbut still think mayweather does it for me with wins like Prime Hatton, Corrales, JLC, DLH etc.