Why did B-Hop, a big MW all his career, stay so long in an unremarkable MW division and fight for peanuts instead of going after the big names at SMW or LHW? Either one of McClellan, Benn, Eubank, Collins or Calzaghe would probably have meant a far bigger pay-day than he got at MW until Tito. Even Nunn and Toney. Not to mention a rematch with Jones. Still, he didn't really seem to go for any of these, despite in being able to move up and without any problems. Hell, he could have moved up and the down if he wanted to continue his dominance at MW. Anyone got any thoughts/insights on this?
Because he would have a tough time with those guys. One thing pretty consistent in the bigger fights he had was his opponents for the most part were one dimensional. Look at the trouble a guy like Taylor gave him who really wasn't that good, but utilized his feet and movement. He could eat up guys that came to him. He blames guys like Jones for not facing him but there's a reason he stayed away from some of the titleists up there. He could have beaten Collins and Eubank probably. I think he would have struggled with Toney Nunn and even Mclellan who is pretty underrated although somewhat one dimensional.
By the time he actually came into prominence at Middleweight most of those guys were pretty much done, or at least close to it. A fight between him and Calzaghe wouldn't really have brought much money at the time either, considering both were relatively unknown titleholders. I suspect he just wanted to rule Middleweight, and that was his goal. There was no need for a rematch with Jones, at least at the time, and Toney was wandering around lost at 175. For the most part, I just don't think he was enough of an attraction for any of the name fighters above him to really accept a challenge, and he wanted to focus on cleaning out Middleweight more than straddling two divisions as a contender. I don't really regard him as a big Middleweight anyway. The weight was perfectly fine for him to be at, and he insisted 154 was possible if he had to go there to get the really big payday against DLH.
I think it's a bit unfair to make very much of the Taylor fights. Look at what kind of opponents these other guys lost to at that age, if they weren't long since retired. These would be tough opponents, though. Perhaps he just didn't want the risk. It's nice to make money, too. Well, he was a big MW. He was 175 for his first fight and he went back up to 175 without any trouble at all. 168 wouldn't have been hard for him. He could have moved up for one fight and then down, without relinquishing his belt. Any of these guys would make him more money than he was making, and a victory over them could his name bigger as well. 1995-1997 would have been the time for this if he wanted any of the big names at SMW. Whether anyone of them wanted any part of him is a different matter, though...
Making millions is better. Won't be that much left of a purse of a 100 or 200 thousand after expenses for the kind of training camp (trainer, sparring partners, handlers etc) that you need to stay on top. Not if you want to retire being set for the rest of your life.
Which brings me back to my answer. He balanced the two issues and made his choice. Then made millions anyway.
160 was his natural weight and there were big paydays with tito and de la hoya to stick around for. him and jones could never agree to a percentage split for a rematch until it was too late. the calzaghe payday in 2002 is a crock. there's never a link for it, just a quote from the late jay larkin who was with showtime. hopkins was an hbo fighter in 2002. why would larkin be negotiating a fight with him?
He was making the weight with ease, 168 was a bit of a wasteland, and personally I don't believe he fancied a trip up to rematch Roy, so he probably thought it'd serve his legacy best to be a long-reigning, dominant, unified champion at his natural weight. He was right.
He turned down 40% to move up to face Jones Jr and ****** offered him the amount he requested to face Calzaghe in 2003 but then he doubled his demands. Did he not fancy the fights or was there other reasons? It's rumoured Don King would take a substancial percentage of his purse but when it came to Roy Jones he just didn't fancy it, he didn't even fancy it in 2007 [ame]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UJbOw_5DPiE[/ame]