Why do so many people on ESB think Calzaghe is P4P #1 or #2?

Do you remember this thread that you started about Kessler-Calzaghe?

http://www.eastsideboxing.com/forum/showthread.php?t=26106

 

Collins better than Calzaghe?? Really

Thats why Collins pulled out of their fight about 10 days before they were due to fight as he couldn't get motivated for it. No he was gonna get his arse whipped and he knew it.

Your arguement could be with Eubank that he was over the hill thats why joe beat him, but also Calzaghe had had less experience. That was Joe's 1st real hard fight, and he came through, he learned loads from that fight.

Benn a possibility, although i think Joe would have edged it due to work rate and speed, plus Benns chin weren't that great.

RJJ yes but joe would have given a good fight
McClellan yes but not a guaranteed winner if they had met

Johnson NO.