Why is it so hard for fans to rate Pac & PBF soundly?

. . . . because everybody has biases. :deal

 

While I respect your post we are going to have to agree on disagreeing.

I am of the opinion that it was a testament of Floyd's skill in regards to ring generalship, to realize he was in danger, not commit any mistakes (while unsure of his poistion as it relates to his legs,head)gather his bearings, recongnize the threat, and neutralize his opponent from capitilazing.

I will agree with you on the fact that so far in Manny's WW run, that he has not been hurt as yet.

In terms of superior speed and conditioning when dealing with Floyd and Manny who has more remains to be seen, until they dance in the squared circle.

Regarding age playng a factor in their bout wheather it is against each other or different opponents I still think Floyd would have been able to pull of the recovery just as he did against Mosely. Since I know you have seen many fights you must give credit when credit is due to Floyds reaction time when he got caught. It was instananeous the tying up of Mosely, who the argument can be made that he took to long to attack. or of Floyds reflexive ability.

I would go with the latter because after reveiwing the fight Mosely did jump on him immeadiately

 

both of their careers have been carefully calculated, they are overrated.