Why is Vitali allowed to sit on the WBC title like a Lame Duck

Discussion in 'World Boxing Forum' started by treeve, Sep 5, 2013.


  1. treeve

    treeve Active Member Full Member

    1,168
    0
    Jan 9, 2010
    Under WBC rules he should be designated as champion in recess or Emeritus

    as per their own rules below
    ARTICLE III - CHAMPIONSHIP OBLIGATIONS

    3.1 Timing of Defenses. A WBC champion shall defend the title in mandatory or voluntary

    defenses at least three (3) times a year, unless a written exception or extension is granted by

    the WBC in its sole discretion. Therefore, a champion must defend his title every one

    hundred twenty (120) unless otherwise permitted by the WBC in its sole discretion. Upon

    10

    winning a title, a champion must defend the title within 90 to 120 days as ordered by the

    WBC, and thereafter every 120 days, in each case unless otherwise ordered or permitted by

    the WBC in its sole discretion.

    3.2 Recognition Subject to Forfeit. A champion who does not defend his title within the

    periods set forth herein shall forfeit his title, unless the WBC in its sole discretion otherwise

    permits. Further, the WBC may also withdraw recognition of a mandatory or qualifying

    challenger for inactivity or failure to engage in any bout ordered by the WBC. A WBC

    champion may not hold a championship of another organization unless permitted by the

    WBC in its sole discretion.

    3.3 Qualified Challengers. Champions shall defend their titles, either in a voluntary or

    mandatory defense, against a challenger (each, a “Qualified Challenger”) in one of the

    following categories:

    (a) any of the top ten (10) rated contenders; or

    (b) with the approval of or ratification by a majority of the Board of Governors,

    (c) under special circumstances and with the approval of or ratification by two-third

    i. any boxer rated 11 to 15;

    ii. a champion or a highly-rated boxer of another weight division;

    iii. another WBC champion, such as a WBC Diamond or Silver Champion,

    Champion Emeritus, or Champion in Recess;

    iv. a former world champion or other elite challenger;

    v. a champion of another boxing organization recognized by the WBC; or

    rd

    (2/3

    ) of the Board of Governors, a contender not otherwise listed in one or more of

    the above categories.

    3.4 Voluntary Defenses. In order to fulfill their requirement to defend the title regularly in a

    timely manner, champions shall propose voluntary defenses against Qualified Challengers

    as defined above. No bout shall qualify as a voluntary defense other than as permitted by

    the WBC in accordance with these Rules and Regulations. Unification bouts with

    champions of other organizations recognized by the WBC must be specifically requested

    and may be approved, denied, or made subject to special conditions by the WBC in its sole

    discretion.

    3.5 Mandatory Defense Obligations. All WBC champions shall make at least one (1)

    mandatory defense per year, unless an exception is granted by the WBC in its sole

    discretion. A champion may be required to make more than one mandatory defense per

    year, if the WBC has designated more than one mandatory challenger for any reason. No

    bout shall be considered a mandatory defense unless specifically approved by the WBC and

    made exclusively against an official mandatory challenger designated by the WBC. A

    challenger who wins the title shall automatically inherit the mandatory defense obligations

    of the champion he defeated, unless the WBC in its sole discretion otherwise directs.

    3.6 Timing and Extensions of Mandatory Defense Obligations. The time periods for

    mandatory defenses stated in these Rules may be altered by the WBC in its sole discretion

    under special circumstances, including if a champion has defended the title in a voluntary

    defense against a contender the WBC may have deemed a mandatory challenger. No

    mandatory bout may be contested until such time as is required for a mandatory defense

    11

    under these Rules and Regulations, including any extensions that may be granted by the

    WBC in its sole discretion.

    3.7 Designation of Mandatory Challengers. The WBC shall always have the discretion to

    designate a mandatory challenger by:

    (a) ordering a final elimination bout of two qualified contenders; or

    (b) designating as official mandatory challenger a Qualified Challenger.

    For the avoidance of doubt, the highest rated (or the highest rated available) boxer in the

    WBC rankings is never, solely by virtue of such position, the official mandatory challenger.

    Notwithstanding anything to the contrary, including any communications attributed to the

    WBC, no boxer shall be considered as or claim any privileges associated with being a

    mandatory challenger unless (i) the boxer has been officially designated as such by the

    WBC Presidency, and (ii) the WBC Board of Governors has voted to appoint or ratify the

    designation of such boxer as mandatory challenger.

    3.8 Special Bout Sanction. Under special circumstances, such as a match involving an elite

    contender, a unification bout, or other match that the WBC determines in its sole discretion

    would be in the best interests of boxing, the WBC may order and/or sanction such bout as

    either a voluntary or mandatory defense, and may order that such special bout take

    precedence over and occur prior to any previously designated mandatory defense.

    Under the circumstances set forth in the preceding paragraph, any previously-designated

    mandatory challenge may be ordered by the WBC: (i) to occur immediately after the

    special bout with no intervening bout, (ii) to be rescheduled to occur after one or more

    voluntary bouts, or (ii) postponed by the WBC until such time as the champion is required

    to defend against his next mandatory challenger, including any extensions that may be

    granted by the WBC in accordance with these Rules and Regulations.

    3.9 Elimination Bouts. The WBC may order one or more qualifying or elimination bouts and

    tournaments to determine ratings and to select the boxers that will compete in a final

    elimination bout to designate an official mandatory challenger. Therefore, not all

    elimination bouts are necessarily to designate the official mandatory challenger, and the

    winner of an elimination bout does not become mandatory challenger unless such bout has

    been sanctioned by the WBC explicitly as a Final Elimination Bout.

    Only the winner of a Final Elimination Bout shall become a mandatory challenger, and

    shall be subject to the provisions of these Rules and Regulations and such additional

    conditions and exceptions as may be imposed by the WBC in its discretion on a case-bycase basis.

    3.10 Suspension or Withdrawal of Recognition Following Elimination Bout. Following an

    elimination or final elimination contest, the WBC may withdraw recognition of the winner

    of such bout as a qualifying or mandatory challenger if the WBC in its sole discretion

    determines: the outcome of the match was controversial or irregular; that despite winning

    the bout, the winner’s performance was unsatisfactory or did not demonstrate the merit to

    advance; if a winner remains inactive for an extended period in advance of his final

    elimination or championship bout; or if it otherwise serves the best interests of the sport.
     
  2. treeve

    treeve Active Member Full Member

    1,168
    0
    Jan 9, 2010
    12

    Under such circumstances, the WBC may order a rematch, order one or more additional

    qualifying, elimination, or final elimination bouts that include or exclude one or both of the

    previous contenders, or designate as a mandatory contender a Qualified Challenger under

    Rule 3.4.

    3.11 Immediate Rematch Policy. The WBC does not recognize immediate rematch clauses in

    bout agreements and will not sanction or authorize immediate rematches, unless it

    determines in its sole discretion, with the approval of or ratification by two-third (2/3

    the Board of Governors, that:

    (a) the conduct or result of the bout was controversial or irregular;

    (b) there is sufficient public demand; or

    (c) a direct rematch would otherwise be in the best interests of boxing.

    3.12 Immediate Rematches. If the WBC determines that a rematch is appropriate pursuant to the

    preceding rule, it may order the rematch as a mandatory bout, permit a requested rematch as

    a voluntary bout, or sanction the bout as a special bout under Rule 3.8.

    If such a rematch is ordered, the winner of the immediate rematch must comply with

    mandatory defense obligations existing at the time of the original contest, and a previously

    designated official mandatory challenger shall instead face the winner of the immediate

    rematch without an intervening bout, unless an exception is granted by the WBC in its sole

    discretion.

    3.13 Rematch after intervening contest. The WBC may also order a rematch as a mandatory

    defense after allowing an intervening contest. In such a case, the winner of the intervening

    contest must face the other participant in the original bout and must comply with mandatory

    defense obligations existing at the time of the original bout, unless an exception due to

    special circumstances is granted by the WBC in its sole discretion.

    3.14 Non-Title Bouts. A WBC Champion must always defend the WBC title if he boxes in the

    same weight division as his championship. A WBC Champion may not engage in any title

    or non-title bout in his weight division, or a title or non-title bout in any other weight

    division, without requesting and receiving a written sanction of the bout from the WBC.

    In such circumstances, the WBC may in its sole discretion authorize a WBC champion to

    engage in such a contest, provided, however, that the WBC Champion has requested and

    consented that the proposed bout be sanctioned as a WBC Special Event to be governed by

    the WBC’s Rules and Regulations, and pays all sanction fees required pursuant to Rule 7.

    The champion’s title is subject to forfeiture for any failure to comply with this Rule.

    3.15 Withdrawal or Suspension of Recognition for Cause. The privilege, trademark, and other

    intellectual property associated with any WBC championship or WBC-sanctioned bout are

    each owned exclusively by the WBC. Therefore, the WBC may suspend or withdraw

    recognition of a boxer as a WBC champion, challenger, or contender for cause, as it may

    determine in its sole discretion. Cause may consist of any reason justifying suspension or

    withdrawal, including but not limited to violation of the WBC Constitution or these Rules

    and Regulations, holding the title of another boxing organization without the approval or

    13

    sanction of the WBC, or conviction and imprisonment for a crime involving moral turpitude

    or other serious moral offense.

    3.16 Petition for Reconsideration. In the event that WBC recognition is suspended or withdrawn

    under these Rules, such action will be deemed final, and the WBC may undertake any

    action to fill a vacant title or establish challengers as it may deem appropriate in its sole

    discretion, provided, however, that the affected party may request reconsideration solely in

    accordance with Article V hereof.

    3.17 Filling a Vacant Title. If a title becomes vacant for any reason, the Board of Governors

    may in its discretion take whatever steps or actions it deems necessary or appropriate to fill

    the title, including but not limited to:

    (a) instituting a tournament or elimination contest(s) among Qualified Challengers;

    (b) Ordering a championship contest between two Qualified Challengers; or

    (c) recognizing as champion the winner of a previous elimination bout.

    This list is non-exclusive.

    3.18 Conditions upon New Champion. The WBC may, as it in its discretion deems proper and

    necessary, impose conditions upon a new champion filling a vacant title, including but not

    limited to: (a) ordering the first defense of the title as a mandatory defense against a WBCdesignated challenger (who may be any Qualified Challenger or a challenger selected

    through a final elimination bout. Upon request, the WBC may in its discretion approve one

    or more voluntary defenses prior to ordering a mandatory defense.

    3.19 Inactivity of a Champion. If a WBC Champion is or may become inactive in a manner that

    may prevent him from fulfilling his voluntary and mandatory defense obligations, the WBC

    may declare the championship vacant and order one or more bouts to fill the vacant title.

    Such inactivity may be either (i) a period of past and continuing inactivity or (ii) potential

    future inactivity that may prevent a champion from defending his title in a timely manner as

    required under these Rules.

    The WBC may make such a determination based upon special circumstances, which may

    include, but not be limited to:

    (a) medical issues or injury;

    (b) legal issues or contractual impediments;

    (c) personal or family issues; or

    (d) other controversy or circumstances whether or not beyond the control of the boxer

    or the WBC.

    It is the sole responsibility of a WBC Champion to notify the WBC in writing in a timely

    manner of any special circumstances that may prevent him from complying with his title

    defense obligations. In the event that a champion fails to notify the WBC in a timely

    14

    manner of such circumstances, the WBC may take appropriate actions including vacating

    the title or imposing other penalties.

    3.20 Champion in Recess. In certain cases under the preceding Rule, the WBC may in its

    discretion designate a Champion as a “Champion in Recess”, such that upon the boxer’s

    return, he will qualify to box for the championship as an elite contender for the new

    champion, or as the returning champion. The WBC may order or permit a returning

    Champion in Recess to box directly for the title in a mandatory or voluntary contest, or to

    box one or more Qualified Challengers in order to retain his status as Champion in Recess.

    A Champion in Recess may return as a mandatory challenger, but only upon the prior

    written approval of such status by the WBC Board of Governors, which may approve or

    deny such request in its sole discretion.

    3.21 Diamond Championship. In its discretion, on such terms and conditions as it may impose,

    the WBC may designate one current WBC Diamond Champion of the World in each weight

    division. The WBC Diamond Championship may be awarded to recognize the most

    extraordinary and elite boxer in a division, as an honorarium or as a title under such terms

    and conditions as the WBC may designate in its sole discretion. Under extreme special

    circumstances, the WBC may in its discretion designate the Diamond Champion as supreme

    champion in the division, subject only to such obligations to defend the title as the WBC

    may impose or permit in its sole discretion, upon an affirmative vote by the WBC Board of

    Governors. The Diamond Champion may be permitted to voluntarily defend the title;

    however, the Diamond Championship may be not won by a challenger unless a special

    sanction is granted by the WBC in its sole discretion. The WBC may also order the

    Diamond Champion to comply with all defense and other obligations applicable to WBC

    World Champions hereunder.

    3.22 Silver Championship. In its discretion, on such terms and conditions as it may impose, the

    WBC may designate or order and award WBC Silver Championships of the World in each

    weight division. The WBC Silver Championship is a world title superior to all WBC

    championships except the World or Diamond Championships. The WBC may designate

    the challengers for a Silver Championship from among any Qualified Challengers. A Silver

    Champion must comply with all defense and other obligations applicable to WBC World

    Champions hereunder as the WBC shall order in its discretion. A Silver Champion shall

    not be a mandatory contender for the WBC World Championship absent winning a final

    elimination bout for the World title, unless a written exception has been approved by a

    majority vote of the WBC Board of Governors in its sole discretion.

    3.23 Champion Emeritus. In its discretion, the WBC may, upon a 2/3

    Governors, designate in each weight category one or more WBC Champions Emeritus. The

    recognition of WBC Champion Emeritus may be bestowed upon a present or past WBC

    World Champion of extraordinary prestige, reputation, stature, or everlasting legacy in the

    sport. A WBC Champion Emeritus shall also be an Ambassador of Good Will on behalf of

    the WBC.

    A WBC Champion Emeritus shall be free to display and exhibit his special belt in any

    social ceremony or sports event. The WBC Champion Emeritus recognition is the highest

    of honors granted by the WBC to any boxer, and cannot be ceded to anyone inside or

    outside the ring. Champion Emeritus recognition may be withdrawn only by the WBC its

    sole discretion in the event that a holder of this recognition affiliates with another boxing

    organization or otherwise brings dishonor upon the WBC or the sport of boxing.
     
  3. treeve

    treeve Active Member Full Member

    1,168
    0
    Jan 9, 2010
    A

    15

    Champion Emeritus has the right to request an immediate challenge to the WBC World

    Champion without first boxing in an elimination contest, and if a mandatory challenger has

    previously been designated, the WBC may order that the Champion Emeritus compete first

    for the title as an immediate mandatory challenger, but in any event, only upon the prior

    written approval of such status by the affirmative vote of the WBC Board of Governors,

    which may approve or deny such request in its sole discretion.
    :deal:deal


    Clearly Vitali's age and injury prone body need to retire and let a young up and coming boxer shine in the spotlight. Not to mention he hounded Lewis for close to a year and still mopes about the fight, but the hypocrite is doing the exact same thing sitting on the title while growing old and not defending the most prized belt in boxing.:rasta
    :nono
    Interesting that no-ones heard from CHEF in a while. (yes he's probably busy with Vlad's training camp, but he usually finds time to grace the forum)
     
  4. SimplyTheBest

    SimplyTheBest Heavyweight Destroyer Full Member

    10,415
    253
    Feb 3, 2010
    CHEF has more important things to do right now, as he usually does during training camp. Nothing "interesting" about it. :roll:
     
  5. itsmeagain1

    itsmeagain1 Guest

    Vitali bribed them. Which is laughable when you consider his so called anti corruption political ticket he is trying to sell
     
  6. Rico Spadafora

    Rico Spadafora Master of Chins Full Member

    45,372
    3,783
    Feb 20, 2008
    Vitali is the Prestigious WBC Champion Emeritus. He can do what he wants and all indications are he is going to fight Stiverne early next year.
     
  7. shavers

    shavers Well-Known Member Full Member

    2,274
    388
    Jul 21, 2004
    Vitali is a disgrace to the sport, a fraud, a ducker and a greedy man. I hope the fool retires so we can get rid of him and his imbecile fans...
     
  8. jasper2005

    jasper2005 Active Member Full Member

    920
    2
    Jun 8, 2012
    "upon thier sole discretion" the WBC can do w/e the **** they want basically is what that whole thing u quoted says
     
  9. iceman71

    iceman71 WBC SILVER Champion Full Member

    51,687
    23
    Jul 28, 2008
    the WBC also says they will strip anyone who unifies the WBC title with another belt.
    yet they didnt do this to danny garcia as he is a WBC champ and WBA....
    bottom line is they only enforce what rules they feel like it, when it best suits them...thats why the WBC is a clown operation these days
     
  10. SimplyTheBest

    SimplyTheBest Heavyweight Destroyer Full Member

    10,415
    253
    Feb 3, 2010
    :deal
     
  11. ludwig

    ludwig Boxing Addict Full Member

    5,049
    59
    Apr 29, 2010
    His last mandatory defense was almost 2 years ago, so the TS has a point.

    Vitali has to fight Stiverne or retire.
     
  12. iceman71

    iceman71 WBC SILVER Champion Full Member

    51,687
    23
    Jul 28, 2008
    the WBC stripped Bradley (quick!) when he didnt defend against Khan....and made the title vacant for (i believe garcia vs morales)
    the whole point is they will strip who the f u c k they want when they want
    if it fits their corrupt agenda
     
  13. Farmboxer

    Farmboxer VIP Member Full Member

    86,106
    4,096
    Jul 19, 2004
    How did Wilder get ranked in the top ten without fighting anyone ranked at all? Vitali will fight Stiverne, knock him and I hope he will go ahead an knock Wilder out before he retires. Why does Wilder not have to fight any ranked fighters in any Org.?! Vlad has mentioned fighting Wilder, I just hope he does this right after he fights Povetkin. Compare Vitali and Vlad's opponents with Wilder's! There is not comparison!
     
  14. Cletis VanDamme

    Cletis VanDamme Boxing Addict Full Member

    3,429
    452
    Jun 5, 2012
    Because Vitali does what Vitali wants to. :bart
     
  15. MrMagic

    MrMagic Loyal Member Full Member

    39,534
    71
    Oct 28, 2004
    Because Sulaiman loves Vitilli.

    He had him champion emeritus for so long, and now this.. disgraceful, Vittilli is a true champion but lets be fair here.