Whatever gave Wilder that freakish unorthodox ability to obliterate, has gone. You can just see it. I think it's age. He had this youthful genetic that just kicked in and connected somehow. He still wants to commit to a knockout, but that wire-y power just isn't there! AJ has been in an almost managed decline for years now. Some say since Wlad, some Ruiz. It's funny though, because I'd say the most complete tuned-in we saw AJ, was Usyk II in '22.
I think one of the things missing to what you have written is that, that wasn't Joshua's run of opponents and record when Usyk fought him Joshua was a unified champion at that time with only one avenged defeat Outside of that, I don't think Wilder is a bad opponent for Usyk. Neither are getting any younger
Since 2019: Joshua Won: Ruiz, Pulev, Franklin, Helenius, Wallin, Ngannou, Jake Paul Lost: Ruiz, Usyk, Usyk, Dubois Wilder Won: Breazeale, Ortiz, Helenius, Herndon, Chisora Lost: Fury, Fury, Parker, Zhang Now that Wilder's beaten Chisora, there isn't much difference. Paul is probably the worst opponent either man beat, worse than Herndon. Ortiz is probably the best. Chisora too is a good win, adjusted for age.
If we're taking 2019 into consideration, Wilder may get a slight advantage over AJ. It was the best year of his career and both Breazeale and Ortiz are good wins.
You bring up an interesting point. I think AJ prepared extremely hard and precise for Usyk II and when he still lost I think that took a lot out of him. He realized nothing he could do would change anything against Usyk and I think it’s affected him since.
Agree with both parts of your comment What gave Wilder freak one punch KO was his twitch speed and reflexes, being able to turn into the straight right at inhuman speed. Those reflexes and speed have gone now, so while he still has heavy clubbing power, his one punch KO power that resulted from his speed is gone
I think there is still a fair difference. The best win for either was Ruiz for Joshua Helenius, they both hold a clear win Wallin beat Breazeale Pulev had beaten a younger version of Chisora and not a 42 year old version I think Franklin was likely rated higher than Herndon I'm not saying it is massive but I certainly think Joshua even at this stage in his career overall has been winning at a higher level I do agree with Paul being the worst opponent as he wasn't a HW
There are no mental gymnastics required. Tell me Otto Wallin's best win at HW, and I'll tell you if that's worthy of entering the top 10. The desperation of fanboys to give Joshua ANY kind of accolade is comical.
Wallin was seen as a consensus Top 10 guy at the time AJ fought him, including many of the posters on this site. Crying and denying the reality won't help you with this one.
I don't have to tell you anything. He was a consenus Top 10 guy at that time. It can be verified by a few second search on the internet. I won't debate opinions when we have the facts.
You reference a defunct boxing website, and "TBRB" which had him rank 5 for beating an inactive cruiserweight and want me to accept that as fact. He doesn't have a credible HW win which is why you can't name one, and he doesn't pass the eye test. He went on to get brutalized by 41 year old Chisora, further proving he was never on that level.
He was rated Top 10 by all the independent ranking outlets, 3 out of 4 sanctioning bodies and by majority of the posters on this page who gave thir Top 10 lists. You can cry about it in 10 or even 20 more posts - facts don't care about your feelings.
This is where we differ. Rankings are highly susceptible to the influence of money and hype. They differ from reality almost always. You can point to some organization that had Otto Wallin at #5 - what does it mean? Why did they have him at #5? Can YOU explain his ranking? Or can you only hide behind "well this is what these people think". I don't care for the opinions of people who have Otto Wallin at rank 5 if there's no logic behind it. How about you tell me, in 2024, how many of these fighters Otto Wallin demonstrated superiority over based on his performances: Usyk Chisora Joshua Fury Kabayel Parker Dubois Wilder Joyce Zhang Hrgovich Miller Ortiz Ruiz Ajagba Sanchez Bakole Anderson Pulev You probably won't. You can meekly say "but these people said this!" in a weak attempt to prop up poor Otto.