Gómez destroys Rigo and it wouldn't even take very long. (and I probably think more highly of Rigo h2h in historical fantasy matchups than most)
I'd point out this lacks a poll, but it would likely be a pointless exercise as nobody who isn't trolling (or an extremely patriotic-to-a-fault Cuban) is going to vote for Rigondeaux.
Wilfredo Gomez at 122 was about as good as it gets. Not only would he beat Rigondeaux, but everybody else in the history of the super-bantamweight class. Extremely good boxer vs All-time great.