With Vitali's retirement soon to come. Where do you place him among the ATGS?

Where did I say top 5? I clearly said top 13-15 didn't I? :huh

 

Care to be specific? :yep

 

Klit huggers embarassing themselves once again. RUSKULL further establishes his status as the worst Klit Nazi on ESB.

 

No, because they have no other accomplishments to back that up. It could be argued that the McCall stoppage was early.............

 

**** off! See how easy it is to be tough online............... :rofl

 

More backup, in a little late. :yep

 

So he gets credit for his brothers achievments? That is weak :-(

Peter is perfect for VitKlit, slow, short, crude & easy to hit; plus he was overweight, past his best & had already been beaten.

Using stats is also weak, especially given the context he's achieved them in & against his level of opposition. Its like arguing that Valero is better than Duran or Whitaker because of his perfect KO record.

 

Cool, I also like to concentrate on thing we can all agree on rather than those things that separate us............

 

I like the way you fit that racist crap in to your comment..........smooth. :rofl

 

By Klit hugger logic, Matthysse is an ATG.

 

No it isn't because I wasn't comparing those stats alone. Nice try...........

 

It's the same thing as saying Tyson was the youngest, Foreman was the oldest, Louis had the most defenses, etc.

Stats are very important. :deal

Peter outboxed Toney TWICE. Keep that in mind before bashing him..........

 

atsch

 

Needs a little work

 

Matthysse has wins over Soto, Alexander and arguably Judah. I don't see a single name on Vitali's resume better than that. In addition to that, Matthysse has a ridiculous KO% while being 100lbs lighter.
He'd probably be a H2H nightmare to anyone at that weight.

How is that "logic" any different from yours?