Witherspoon, Dokes, Page, Coetzee, Tubbs, Thomas, Berbick

I personally think that Mike Weaver should be in the mix of this, and probably rates higher than a fair number of them. He did beat a good number of the better ranked heavyweights including John Tate, Gerrie Coetzee, James Tillis, Carl Williams, along with the controversial draw with Dokes and giving a lot of top guys fits.. The fact that his loss column is pretty heavy prevents him from being rated over say, a guy like Witherspoon, but I still pick him as being one of the best of that era.

 

I also think Tucker should be added, Smith too, but I wouldnt put him above Berbick. List is pretty close to mine though.

 

Hoooooooooooooook!:smoke

 

1-Witherspoon
2-Dokes
3-Thomas
4-Tubbs
5-PAge
6-Coetzee
7-Berbick

 

1) Witherspoon
2) Coetzee
3) Dokes
4) Thomas
5) Page
6) Berbick
7) Tubbs.

As Natonic mentioned, Page would be at the top based on ability.