would beating pacquiao make cotto p4p no.1 in your opinion?

Dayaaamm.. I've never sen those stats before. Very impressive.

 

It wasn't a normal fight. With the plaster controversy you CANNOT treat that loss like any regular loss, like it or not.


And, if Clottey won half of the rounds that night, and I am being extremely generous with that, he still loses cuz of the KD. If Clottey would have won 7 rounds, which he sure as hell didn't, it would have been a draw.

 

Floyd to #1 ? your havin a laugh sunshine.
First floyd needs to come out of his comfort zone and fight some real fighters in his own weight and size !!
I would make cotto #3 if he wins.
Floyd in and around top 5, for what its worth i will have paq at 1 no matter what happens tonight !

 

Yes it will Cotto is basicly undefeated, according to all the Floyd Boys, Margaritos record should be erased.....

 

No it wouldn't...if Clottey won 7-5 he would have won 114-113.

But I agree with the rest!!!:good

 

I agree he has to step up and take more fights but no one but Floyd or Pac deserve to be no.1. 70% of lists have him in the top 2 right now "sunshine".

 

yes without a doubt

 

cotto would have beaten 2 guys that are currently in the top 4 p4p
which imo would make him no 1

 

I agree he would have also beat the guy (Pacquiao) who is number one who also holds a win over Marquez #2 guy who Floyd just fought.

So that would make it look some what like this
Cotto
Mayweather
Pac

 

If Cotto wins it and the fight is very close with a split decision, Pac will keep it just because of the size.

If it was a unanimous decision or KO, I will say YES! Let Floyd prove it otherwise by fighting Cotto.

 

IT would really throw a spanner in the mix, thats for sure.

I say the standings if Cotto is to win would be and should be this.

1. PBF
2. Cotto
3. Pacman

 

Agreed.

 

If Cotto wins convinvcingly, he becomes P4P number one.

 

:good is cotto beat pac 2 or 3 p4p rank need mayweather

 

Top 3-5