Would Calzaghe have been the best ever if his hands had stayed injury free?

No no no and no. Calzaghe would lose to Ward, prime B Hope and RJJ just off the top of my head. As soon as SMW started heating up he retired faster than wylie coyote.

 

James Toney would've spanked him at 168.

 

Joe C's busy style would open him up to be countered to death by Toney.

 

Yet here you are also posting back to me again. You see this is the difference. You have been name calling and saying how you feel which seems to matter to you, whereas I dont have any opinion of you and was discussing boxing. You say im this and that following you around even though you are replying to me also, but you are the only one that seems to be showing such emotion. I didnt realize you were so weak

 

What was Toneys best SMW win?

Lets look at Toney when he was a SMW


A post improvised from silencer below and mostly not my work but interesting all the same
look at the level Toney was fighting at, when SMW champ

1993 he wins the title from iran barkley a fighter who years earlier was blown away by nigel benn in 1 round and pummelled to a loss by a shot roberto duran barkley went onto lose 11 out of 25 fights following this fight and never beat anyone who was remotely good in doing so,the guy was so desperate he was even plying his trade as a HW in the late 90's against the likes of berbick and they say this era is a joke

govonor chambers a guy with a career record of 9 wins 7 losses, all 3 fights prior to toney were ko losses!

ricky thomas: won 11 lost 14,the 4 fights he had prior to toney all losses!

glenn thomas:won 29 lost 8, lost to roy jones prior to toney and finished his career with a first round ko loss to jeff lacy.

danny garcia: won 30 lost 22, was coming off losses to chris pyatt (a steve collins victim) lamar parks etc

larry prather: won 19 lost 24,lost his last 5 fights prior to the toney fight even losing to nicky piper

tony thornton: won 37 lost 7,lost to chris eubank a year earlier.

anthony hembrick: won 31 lost 8,lost to maske prior to toney and orlin norris a year earlier.

tim littles: won 27 lost 3,maybe one of his better wins,had fought mainly bums with the exception of a close UD over frankie liles,went onto lose to frankie liles in a 2nd contest following the toney fight.

vinsom durham: won 21 lost 37 enough said.

charles williams: won 37 lost 7 drew 3,lost to maske prior to toney.
(this post was improvised from ESB great Silencer, on one of his great threads)and finally the Jones fight and, That was Jones big SMW victory where Toney was allegedly weight weakened, other than that Jones didnt do much at SMW.

 

I'm only replying to you to tell you to f*ck off Failey. You decided to try (And keep trying) and enter my world. Go be desperate for attention with someone else.

 

so facts are not facts to you...becos someon else is a jobless dole dossing twat?

that doesnt explain why you ignore facts. try again without losing temper this time, it might help.

 

Yet you keep replying and once again think being on a boxing forum is "trying to enter your world " when I havent asked a personal question about you that I can recall. So full of your own self importance to realize that its not about you (or I) and you are upset stemming from me putting forward an alternative to something you wrote related to boxing on a boxing forum. As said you are the emotional one that seems to think its all about you lol

 

Slow down tiger. I havent finished answering the last post so havent properly read this one yet but as we know Calzaghe was up for the Jones fight. Jones decided he wanted the HW fight. Not sure why that unnerves you so much.

 

I've not lost my temper, I'm just stating a fact regarding yourself.

HerolGee....the joke of ESB....now that's a fact.

 

yep u've lost your temper, thanks for confirming it by doing it again. Hahahaaa

 

Good lord....little lap dog failey is pathetic in his attempts to garner attention.

 

How old are you again.....10?

 

lost yer rag AGAIN.

my my. maybe one day u will answer.

 

Maybe one day you'll accept my offer of a job to get you off the dole and scamming the system to keep your family above the bread line.....I'm here to help you Herol, you have time to make something of yourself.