Would Cotto at 154 had beaten Madrimov?

Assume we mean the 154lb version of Cotto from Yuri Foreman through D-Rod? (even in his losses to Mayweather and Trout during that three year stretch he was in much better form than in his victory over one-dimensional Kamegai and losses to Ali or Canelo).

Best for best idk. It isn't that much of a size advantage for The Dream (1½″ of height and 1½″ of reach), and he has dropped handfuls of rounds to much lesser fighters than Cotto.

 

Madrimov is about to lose to Vergil Ortiz he is getting overrated

 

No shame in loosing to Ortiz tho.

 

Been telling folks they're sleeping on The Mustang for years.

https://www.boxingforum24.com/threads/vergil-the-mustang-ortíz-jr-all-the-hype-is-warranted.664939/

 

The way he KO´d Herrera was just ridiculous. Ive been sold ever since, even tho I do feel that a lot of times he doesn´t really show his talent, but relies more on emotion.

I am picking Madrimov over him, but would not be surprised if Ortiz obliterated Madrimov.

 

Cotto was a proper fighter.

 

Cotto best days were lower than 154. What a fighter.

 

No one knows we don't know what Madrimov's ceiling is yet we need to see how his career pans out the Ortiz fight should give us a decent gauge on Madrimov's level.

 

Doubtful. Cotto was decent at 154

 

I've got Cotto. Madrimov showed against Crawford that he didn't know how to infight or kick it up a gear in the championship rounds.

 

Ortiz started at 140 and has never won a world title. There will be a bit of shame when Ortiz shuts him down with a powerjab, doesn't respect his feints and beats him up.

 

Maybe for you, but not for most others. Ortiz is the favorite going into this one.

And Ortiz was at 140 when he was a freaking teenager. How is this even a relevant point?