Would the Pacquiao-Mayweather fight seal a top 10 ATG ranking?

If Manny beats Floyd...Top10 of all time.

If Floyd beats Manny...Top15 of all time.

However, probably they will fight some other times, and have a couple more good wins, so I think the winner of Floyd/Manny will definitely end up in the Top10 of all time.

 

Floyd took 3 years to be P4P #2 and has never since left that position since 1999. Over a decade of being P4P #1 or #2.

Manny is a recent Top 5 P4P fighter in comparison, with losses, draws, bad decisions and people want to act like his resume is more impressive? Cmon. Don't kid yourself.

 

Floyd was P4P #8 in 1998, and #2 in 1999.

However, his ranking varied between 2000 and 2003. He was, for example, #8 in 2002.

In 2004, he was #2 again. Then, he became #1 in 2005.

 

That is insane. Even at the most generous level I can't see that happening. They need more than 1 meaningful fight.

 

Top 10 atg ? Uh No ..They have to be ranked that high themselves before its even a consideration ..I personally don't have either in the top 10 all time !

 

Pacman appeared in the P4P rankings in 2003, after beating Barrera. He was ranked #5.

In 2006, he was moved to #2.

In 2008, he was moved to #1.

 

make it happen boys

 

Nar wouldnt put any of them higher than SRL , SSR , Armstrong , Duran , Pep , Ali , Greb , Moore , Benny Leonard or Joe Louis. Not for a while yet

 

No...but he has more knockouts than either Pacquiao or Mayweather have fights.