Would u consider Oscar De La Hoya an ATG?

Anyone who questions ODH ATG status should be banned from ESB!!

 

simple, yes!

 

The hell? Is this a seriously question?
Of course he's an ATG. Close thread!

 

yes, great resume, great talent

 

WBC: LWW, WW, LMW
WBA: LMW
IBF: LW
WBO: SFW, LW, MW
Ring: LMW

held 8 major titles in 6 weight classes
Thats ATG status there

 

x2.:good

 

All-Time Great is too damn subjective. Everyone has their own criteria. What, top 20 fighter all-time? Top 30? Top 50? Top 100?

I agree in regards to the rematch.

For the first fight, Chavez was still a champ at 140, even if past his best and got lucky in the Randall rematch (and avoided a rubber match for a decade).

I think that was a pretty good win for DLH.

 

why dont you take a little responsibility for your ignorance and educate YOURSELF. i dont do community service.

 

That's about what I figured.

Can't answer the question, can you Mr Guru?

Keep talking out of your ass....

 

A good fighter, not a great fighter. Great fighters step up to the plate in clutch time. DLH never did. Mosley clearly beat dlh in the 2nd fight. I thought the trinidad fight was close....I could see giving it to dlh.

 

The truth is, DLH wouldnt have even made the olympic team if mosley wasnt asked to step up a weightclass "for the good of the team". He was number one at the weightclass DLH won the gold at and he was asked to step up in weight to make the team stronger. Flat out the dude was spoonfed everything including his gold medal.

 

Out of curiousity, was there anyone who made it to ATG status in your eyes outside of RJJ in the last fifteen years? If yes, who did they beat?

 

Oscar vs. Quartey was incredible and Oscar stepped up the plate and smashed a home run on the 3-2 pitch with 2 out. :good

Mosley didn't do **** in their second fight and was outpunched by something like 100 punches. Give me a break, he knew he lost and his facial expressions after proved that. Even his dad knew he had to get a knock out to win, if the judges were doing their job which wasn't the case.

 

You're absurd. Yea, lets forget all the guys oscar defeated en route to his gold medal. - Dumbass

 

Dude you're so far gone it's not even funny and nobody wants to even debate with you. You're like a crazy old fart whose too drunk and dumb and just mumbles BS