Would you consider Floyd an ATG if he had fought and beaten Kosta, Margarito and Pac?

Floyd is already ATG.

And why people keep mentioning margarito?floyd fought baldomir,judah instead,no difference to me.and margarito fight would be stupid,then we have probaly missed de la hoya fight etc.. And arum keeping floyd in control.stupid move.
Kosta?really?kosta didn't want to fight floyd!and by the way hatton is better win than kosta.

Pacquaio is the only fight that have meant something to floyd's legacy,and also that's more to do with arum why that fight didn't happened.

 

He's an all time great now too. But it would catapult him from somewhere around 35/40 in the top 15...

These would likely be the 3 best wins on his resume..

 

You are really a hater.really margo,kosta in top3?atsch

 

yeah.. His best win imo now is Chico.. Pac and Zoo would def be better wins than Chico, Margie is debateble.

 

Pac would have been only top 3 win.Kosta was past his prime when Floyd was at junior welter,remember hatton beat kosta,everyone were saying kosta was past his prime and is not good win for hatton because of that.

And margo haven't got any big victories before that.if floyd have fight margo i bet you haters would be saying now that floyd ducked baldomir.and fighting baldomir would be definetly be floyd top3 win atsch


Corralles,castillo,alvarez or de la hoya are floyd top 3wins now for me.only pac would be definetly in top 3.kosta maybe if that fight happened 2000-2004.but of course everybody would be dismissing that win somehow,and also floyd was at LW then..and as i earlier said when floyd could have fought kosta,everybody would be saying kosta was past his prime.remember hatton win kosta 2005 and people keep saying kosta was washed up,and no good win for hatton.you people are ridicolous.

 

And Phillips already exposed kosta in late 90's.see we can dismiss other fighters also.

 

And i dont ger the logic behind this,you are yelling that kosta have been top win for floyd.hatton beat kosta and was better than kosta,then undefeated hatton challenges floyd.and is not floyd top 3 win in almost no ones list.how this makes sense?and please don't say kosta was washed up and hatton was too small for floyd.because if you say kosta was washed up,then winning against kosta would do absolutely nothing for floyd resume.

 

Pac and Kostya would definitely make Floyd's resume more intersting, Margo, not really

 

Poor little stumpy hater.

Vince Phillips fought (and KO'd) Tszyu....is he an ATG??

Daniel Santos fought (and beat)Margarito....is he an ATG?

 

Both had their chance but wanted no parts.

If Floyd fought Zoo ya'll would say Kostya was Vince Phillips' bi.tch.

 

Exactly.....the haters are confusing themselves.

 

Zoo was a great win for Hatton what the hell are you guys talking about.

And how am i an hater, i consider Floyd an ATG already, that was my first answer.

But it is what it is. His resume isn't all that great. I mean, Chico is his best win.... His ATG status is mostly based on his terrific abilities and longetivity. Pac, Zoo and Margie would ve definitely made his resume a lot better..

 

It's quite sad. There's absolutely nobody else right now to threaten Mayweather, so they go back to the past and make up woul've been fantasy threats. And just stop already with Concreto already, this disgrace's name should never be mentionned at all. Kosta and Cheato top 3 wins? Do the forum a favor and go put your face underwater for a few minutes.