Would you consider Floyd an ATG if he had fought and beaten Kosta, Margarito and Pac?

add martinez to that list aswell then yes for sure, but i dont like how he thinks he is the best fighter ever when he ducked the best fighters around his division (pacman and martinez)

 

Only if he fights Wladimir Klitsckho At Heavy then 2 weeks later fights Rigo at 122.

 

already an atg

 

to be GOAT he would have to fight and beat Ward + Pac in October, Froch + Pac in November, Wlad + Pac n December, Vitali + Pac in January, Haye + Pac in Febuary, Rigo + Pac in March then have a leg an arm amputated and fight and beat Valuev + Pac in April, Donaire + Pac in May, Chavez + Pac in June, Martinez + Pac in July, GGG + Pac in August

And then he'd probably be ranked no 2 of all time because he would have ducked Khan

 

I would have him in my top 20 maybe even top 15 if he had done that.
He remains in my top 35 now.

 

Floyd should fight Garcia, Brook, Thurman and Alexander. They all have the potential to become big stars (Alexander already is) and will be good names on Floyd's resume in a few years time.

Garcia is top dog at lww, he will pick up world titles at ww.

 

He was dumbass. He was arguably the GOAT at 130.:deal PBF is the truth and has proven dumbasses like you wrong for years. 45-0 Deal with it hater.:hi:

 

he would hav ebeen number 2 behind ali

 

Floyd beat all the guys who beat those guys.....

Hatton beat Kosta

Shane knocked out Maragrito-Why anyone discusses this should be banned Mofo anyway

Marqquez knocked out Pac and was robbed once for sure.

 

Everyone's ranking is subjective. But, consensus seems to be he is already considered one of the top 50 fighters of all time. A win over Pac (pre Bradley) really would have him higher but not the GOAT. Tszyu would not have been quite as big a win. Margarito even less of one...considering how his career turned out.

I don't think Floyd has much else to prove...and in terms of age he is past his prime. He is considered one the best ever, already. Talent and skill-wise it could be argued he is in top 10 best ever.