Wow! The Evidence of Floyd Mayweather's Cherry Picking is Overwhelming

i would say both Judah and Hatton were legit top10 Welters despite their losses to Baldomir and Collazo. Borderline though

 

He meant that since winning the "lineal" welterweight claim (which would mean when he beat Baldomir) Mayweather has not risked it against a top 10 welter.

I would question calling Hatton a top tenner at 147. In his only fight at the weight, he won a razor thin SD over another fighter who is a questionable top tenner (who didn't even belong in the same ring with Shane Mosley not long after that), and then ran back down to 140 for another year or so anyway.

 

i don't rate Floyd as high as most people, but still i never thought Hatton had any shot at beating Floyd. I thought Hatton's win over Tszyu was iffy at best. That he was unimpressive against Urango, and that he was downright bad againt Collazo, who got his ass kicked against Mosley. I also thought Castillo got a gift in his fight before Hatton, and that against Hatton he didn't even try.

At 140, Hatton was a top player, at 147 he was just a fringe contender who barely managed to cherrypick a paper title.

 

Kirk speaks the truth! As long as some floyd fans kid the ass or constantly back others, they will always think they are the ONLY real fans.

 

lets move to the fact that you don't know what the hell your talking about.

first off Mayweather tried to fight Hatton when he was at 140 and Hattons camp said he wasn't ready.. Same thing happened with Cotto when they were both at 140.

the only reason he even moved WW in the first place was he was chasing DLH..

by the way he also fought Sharmba Mitchell at Welterweight but due to your lack of boxing knowledge I wouldn't expect you to know that. Baldomir and Judah were both lineal champs. Judah was lineal champ and Baldomir beat him, which postponed a Floyd fight so that Floyd could Baldomir. He then took on Judah because people said it was a fluke that Judah lost to Baldomir. And as far as Hatton, who gives a **** what weight that fight happened at he still woulda put that ****in midget face first into the ring post.

when PBF moved to WW, Cotto was still at junior WW. Margarito signature win was against Cintron, he still to this day only has one solid win in my eyes and thats against Cotto.

 

yea your right i got mixed up there. people criticized him for takin judah first because baldomir was the lineal champ and judah had just lost to him... thanks for catchin that..

 

I believe PBF is still riding high off his destruction of Corrales who was #5 p4p when Floyd fought him.

Sometimes 1 great win is enough to keep you in the limelight forever. In fact, if Pacquiao had cherrypicked his way after destroying Barrera, and had never fought JMM and Morales, people would rate him higher than they do today. Much higher.

 

the only fighter that a legitmate claim to fight floyd before he retired was Cotto. noone else had done enough, Margarito had losses to Santos and Paul Williams, he didn't beat Cotto until after PBF retired. Williams had a win over Margarito but lost to Quintana shortly after PBF-Hatton. Cotto is the only one that had done enough to be mentioned in the same sentence as Floyd..

People who make this arguement love to forget the fact that Hatton was P4P #2 to most people in the world..

 

Once again you only tell half the truth. PBF offered Hatton a fight back when both were at 140 but Hatton declined, blame Hatton. Why the **** are you trying to act as if PBF didn't make the offer at 140? Let me guess to push your hate filled agenda? The truth is weight had no bearing in that fight. PBF isn't a huge WW like Margo and came in on fight night at around 149 and Hatton weighed more than PBF did. The weight wasn't a factor PBF is a stylistic nightmare for Hatton and would always beat a reckless and wide open guy like him.:deal Like I posted earlier I could do this for Margo, Cotto, hatton or Williams. This is a pathetic attempt to try and tarnish one of the best fighters of the last 25 years.

 

Castillo was considered the best fighter at 135. Did he cherry pick him too you buffoon? :rofl