You gave Maidana the win over Floyd, but had Brook over Porter? Explain!

This. Same exact scores for me.

 

:deal

 

:deal, this is right

i don't know how any one can have maidana winning the fight against money may.

i can see people having porter winning over brook because the fight was in the US, the defending champion was american and the judges tend to go with the busier fighter.. for that reason you could have had porter up by a round or two. But if you score it neutrally without any of this in mind brook was winning it easy... on the other hand if the same fight is in england then the scores would read 120-108 brook

 

:?

 

Maidana and Floyd was a closer fight.

Brook vs Porter was a schooling is my best guess (I had Mayweather winning anyway)

 

2 completely different fights. The Mayweather/Maidana fight was closer.

I've said this once and I'll say it again.

A case can be made for Maidana winning 5 of the first 6 rounds against Floyd. Even a Mayweather fan had gave Maidana 5 of the first 6 rounds if I recall. Maidana had a strong Round 8 which gave him enough rounds to make it a draw. And there were a number of swing rounds from round 6-12.

Floyd struggled a lot more against Maidana than Brook against Porter.

 

Why do you insist on acting like a jr high schoolkid & calling Tony Margarito Concreto?? Show me one iota of proof he ever did anything illegal or shut the hell up and grow up. Its just because he scared the crap out of your idol Mayweather isn't it . His name should be Floyd Poop Mayweather lol

 

it is hypocrisy if they had Maidana winning but not Porter.

i had Floyd and Kell because, well, they won the fight. both Marcos and Shawn were ineffective all night. complete dross from the two of them.

i really hope Marcos doesn't smother his punches this time. he needs to leave some room to get his punches off, just smothering again will result in a pointless fight. he needs to give himself a chance. lets see if he will.

 

:good Maidana probably did a bit better than Porter, but certainly not enough to warrant a rematch.