your boxing statements that people will find controversial?

RJJ was unbeatable at 168 and down a true stylistic terror for anyone in the history of the sport.

Joe Calzaghe is underrated here a great fighter who would have been great in any era.

PBF schools Pac if they ever fight I mean makes him look amateurish.

Gamboa is a knock out waiting to happen.

Donaire is more talented and more complete than Pac.

Cotto is one of the most overrated fighters of this era.

Hearns is underrated

 

I agree he has the ability but he's to mentally weak to actually pull it off.

 

technicly floyd mayweather is the best boxer ever

my p4p top ten doesnt have henry armstrong in it

neither jack "boring to watch" johnson

and neither harry "basicly no footedge" greb

roy jones jr. is #2 at my best boxer ever list

felix trinidad beats thomas hearns @154

 

at smw YES

at lh NO why? because dawson is naturaly bigger stronger, the harder puncher and not far away from being as or nearly as athletic as direll if dawson comes well prepared and with the mind set to put things to work

 

BECAUSE THEY ONLY DO IT FOR BIG FIGHTS AND MAYWEATHER/TZYU WASN'T CONSIDERED A BIG FIGHT BACK THEN atschatsch

 

give donaire half a year of preparation and he beats timothy, without timmy being weight drained!!

 

Chavez beat Whitaker.

 

And Donaire is an HBO fighter that's not a draw yet he is willing to fight the winner of the Showtime tournament.

Neither Dawson, Johnson, Hopkins, or Pascal are big draws yet they were willing to go to opposite networks in order to make fights happen. :good

 

Gatti/Ward sucked.

 

well you should go back in time and tell that to those networks

 

No, tell it to the fighters. They're legacy is on the line, not HBO or Showtime's. HBO and Showtime will still make money without boxing. True fighters will move through all this network and promoter BS to make fights they want happen. '

Can you imagine Leonard, Hearns, Duran, and Hagler saying they can't fight each other or anyone else because they are on opposite networks? Neither can I.

 

:good

 

Valero would have beaten Pac 2/3 times in an epic trilogy.

 

probably because those are some of the biggest fights in history :roll:

Plus why don't you put blame on Kosta for the fight not happening. Floyd has expressed interest in this fight multiple times
Do you remember him(Tzyu) getting a shoulder injury in training for his rematch with Mitchell which was scheduled for Feb 7th 2004

He then rehabilitated and fought the rematch in November when Mayweather debutted in the division in May of 2004. Floyd then fought Bruseles next in January of 2005. He actually called out Tzyu again after that fight

Kosta then fights Hatton next in the summer and lost:hi:

 

More than enough time to make that fight happen. And the first or second fight at 140 isn't an excuse. Floyd was Marquez first fight above 135 and Hatton and Ortiz 2nd fight at welterweight. What's your excuse for Shane and Oscar not fighting Tszyu?