Your new p4p top 5?

Why is JMM still in people's top p4p ??Anyways

1.PBF
2.Paquio
3.Joe C
4.Miguel Cotto
5.Bernard Hopkins

 

why shouldn't he? you got pac at 2, so how can the gap between these two be so big that you fill it with at least 3 other fighters?

 

Harrison
Williams
Sprott (seriously thinking about putting him no2)

 

Because he hasn't won a signifigant fight since his win over Rocky Juarez thats why!He has yet to look impressive even in his win over Barrera ..

 

1. Mayweather
2. Pacquiao
3. Calzaghe
4. Cotto
5. Vasquez
6. JMM
7. Hopkins
8. Pavlik
9. Wladimir
10.

 

Before anyone starts bitching about my p4p list because PBF isn't #1 or whatever, it's because the mother ****er doesn't fight no one..

01. Manny Pacquiao
02. Joe Calzaghe
03. Miguel Cotto
04. Floyd Mayweather
05. Juan Marquez

Others somewhere on the list would include Hopkins, Vasquez, Calderon, & Pavlik..

 

EXPALIN!

EXPLAIN!

EXPLAIN!

 

(edit: directed to imperial)
so you're saying you're only going by who won against who, not taking into consideration your personal feel of who's the best and who not? to me this kind of scoring is nicely done by boxrec, but personally other factors are more important.

to me, even though i'm not even yelling "robbery" (it was an alright decision - and before you ask, i had pac winning the first fight kinda clearly) jmm won against pac. so how could i rank him lower? but i regard pac as one of the best fighters right now, this gives jmm a spot right in the top 5.

it's that hypothetical p4p ranking... you can't exactly tell who took an imaginary title from who and so on.. it's really weird that you got pac at 2 and jmm, who fought arguably just as good, isn't even ranked.

 

1- Mayweather
2- Pavlik
3- Calzaghe
4- Pacquiao
5- Cotto

Other notables :

- Haye
- Klitschko
- Israel Vasquez
- Juan Manuel Marquez
- Hopkins

Awww man! You have to explain something to me Punch 13

Paulie Malignaggi!?

You got to be kidding...

 

1.PBF
2.PAc
3.Calzaghe
4.JMM
5.Cotto

 

1) Mayweather
2) Calzaghe
3) Pacquiao
4) Cotto
5) Izzy Vazquez


It honestly is really hard to make this lb4lb list because the top fighters are clearly really making a case for themselves as far as opposition is concerned.

 

Calzaghe shouldent gain anything from the fight yesterday, he was poor!

 

This is why I am thinking about putting Cotto at #2. He is younger and better at this point in his carrer than Calzaghe and Pacquiao are. #2 and 3 p4p have struggled in their last performances, but against world class proven champions.

 

you dont understand boxing :yikes

 

1. Mayweather
2. Calzaghe
3. Cotto
4. Pacquiao
5. JM Marquez
6. Pavlik
7. Vasquez
8. R Marquez
9. Hopkins
10. Mosley