Your p4p top 5 after last night

Yeah but Floyd is a Welter really so its like saying if Floyd fought Sergio at MW would Sergio be P4P1?

 

mine doesnt change

mayweather
pac
donaire
jmm
serg

 

Sorry mate but I can't see any explanation for Donaire being higher than JMM. He only really has two world class wins in his career - how many has Marquez had ??

 

jmm has been on the slide though, he still lost last night had he got the decision things would be so different

 

Thought he put on a career best performance Sat night! Not sure he's on the slide..

 

These are fans rankings. Just because 3 men at ringside got it wrong doesn't mean that JMM didn't win in the fans eyes.

 

PBF,
PAC,
JMM
Sergio
Gamboa

 

:-(

 

Why not?

The guy is one of the best in the World.

 

P4P isn't calculated on talent, it's on records.

 

both fights were at Welterweight. All of the fighters came up from much lower weight classes. Should Mayweaters legacy be punished because he gradually rose through the ranks and build his body rather than just jumping.

 

Well, should Sergio Martinez be anywhere near there then? Surely B-Hop should be?

 

Of course Sergio should. In the last 2 years: 2 wins over previously P4P top 10 (seriously) Paul Williams, Win over Cintron, Win over #1 middleweight Pavlik and beat couple of decent contenders in Barker and Dzinziruk.

 

Mayweather is the best fighter in the game, I dont like his persona, but he's the best and has been since the slide of RJJ.
Marquez is my fav fighter, and the 2nd best.
Pac, Hopkins, Martinez, Vitali, Donaire are the best of the rest so:

1.Mayweather
2.Marquez
3.Pac
4.BHop
5.Vitali(Im no Klit fan or nuthugger, but when was the last time he came close to losing, but countering that when was the last time he fought anything but a heavybag on legs!)

 

1. Mayweather
2. Juan Manual Marquez
3. Manny Pacquiao
4. Sergio Martinez
5. Nonito Donaire