Your Pound For Pound Top 10

I was gonna make this thread! I guess Euro-level minds think alike.

1) Manny Pacquiao
2) Floyd Mayweather
3) Sergio Martinez
4) Juan Manuel Marquez
5) Timothy Bradley
6) Nonito Donaire
7) Juan Manuel Lopez
8) Wladdy Klitschko
9) Bernard Hopkins
10) Steve Cunningham

I personally wouldn't have Wonjongkam near my top 10. He has very few wins of real importance in recent years. His resume consists mostly of novices and journeymen. The Kameda win was good, but P4p top 10? Nah!

Ward only has 1 top win. Green, Bika and Miranda are very average wins IMO.

Adamek? :rofl

 

Still bitter about last night eh davy-boy?

To bad that's not what I said. My problem is that your only reason for rating Martinez higher then mayweather is that floyd hasn't fought in 9 months....if you think that makes Martinez a better fighter then Floyd just say "I think floyd is stoo rusty and not as sharp as he used to be"...thats an idiot statement but at least a defensible one. But thats not what your saying....basically your implying that you've "punished" floyd for not fighting enough....which is laughable given that p4p is a mythical ranking list of who are the most talent/best practisioners of boxing at all weights....your hate for floyd runs deep my son. Before you call me a ***** or whatever just know I could give a **** about the guy.


Anyways guys here's my list:

This content is protected

This content is protected

This content is protected

This content is protected

This content is protected

This content is protected

This content is protected

This content is protected

This content is protected

This content is protected

 

My top 5

Pac
Floyd
Martinez
Donaire
Wlad

 

1. Pacquiao
2. Mayweather
3. Martinez
4. Donaire
5. Marquez

 

Pac(not for long if he continues with joke fights)
Floyd(not for long if he remains inactive)
Donaire
Martinez
Hopkins
Jmm
Segura
Lopez
Wlad

Number ten is open for debate. Pascal, agbeko, bradley, froch and others.

 

1- manny pacquiao- fights nothing but the best for 10 years.., fights anyone
2- mayweather (very close to dropping significantly due to inactivity and having no balls to fight pacquaio)
3- wladimir klitschko - dominated heavyweight division for 6 years without a bruise on his face to show for it
4 vitali klitschko - undefeated in 7 years. pushing 40 and still cant get a fighter to give him a challenge or even win a round
5 bernard hopkins - 46...fearless...can hold his own against the likes of top fighters like jean pascal, and make them look bad..
6- juan manuel marquez
7- timothy bradley
8- lucian bute
9 martinez
10- david haye

 

i agree but i have froch ahead of kessler because of his better resume and willingness to travel.

 

wow, everyone's basically got Donaire within the top 5! Looks like the hatorade and skepticism have been swept away....
yeah..... he's been rolling good competition like that for some time
if you watch him fight, you can tell he's got ALL the goods, including being an EXTREMELY under-estimated intelligent puncher.

I would compare his punch intelligence to the level of PBF, he can deliver it just as fast but drop it harder though, per weight comparison. He looks not only to control and break you down with his punches, but also to drop the hammer. You can tell he fully commits his punches, and has the confidence of their effectiveness and timing...

If PBF is unable to get a fall fight w/ an A-class opponent, imo Donaire will unseat him at #2 at that time....

 

If nothing else changes I also disagree that floyd should be higher. If Nonito roles Agbeko and perez/darchynian winner in the meantime then you got to start considering it. But ya as things stant unless you are a huge believer in the kid's abilities and can see more into the future then most of us floyd should be higher IMO as he has shown himself over a career's worth of fights to be on a different level then basically everyone he's fought accept Castillo (twice, lost the first one...was injured, could have won it but was inexperieince and didn't do enough, second fight was a tough one too IMO).

 

yeah sorry ward!lol my brain did fox new reporter then. i think froch has a better resume than ward dont u think?

 

Cotto? Why?