Your round by round scoring for Calzaghe - Hopkins...

This is mainly directed at the 'people' who scored the fight to Hopkins, but all scorecards are welcome.

I am only interested in round by round scores. I need this level of information from your minds to diagnose, educate and ultimately cure you who doubt Calzaghe won that fight.

 

1 10-8 Hopkins
2 10-9 Hopkins
3 10-9 Hopkins
4 10-9 Hopkins
5 10-9 JC
6 10-9 JC
7 10-9 JC
8 10-9 JC
9 10-9 JC
10 10-9 Hopkins
11 10-9 JC
12 10-9 JC

Calzaghe 114-113 Hopkins

 

China_hand_Joe: "If Hopkins signs to fight Joe, I will tip my hat and leave ESB forever"

When that came around, you edited your **** to;
China_hand_Joe: "If Hopkins lands over 20 punches, I will tip my hat and leave ESB forever"

Not only did he hit him, he floored him.

 

My scorecard is entirely accurate and i will refuse to accept any critism about my scoring of the fight :yep

 

I can't remember my exact scorecard, but in the end it was 114-113 for Calzaghe.

 

BH - JC

1. 10 - 8
2. 10 - 9
3. 10 - 9
4. 9 - 10
5. 9 - 10
6. 10 - 10
7. 10 - 9
8. 9 - 10
9. 9 - 10
10. 10 - 9
11. 9 - 10
12. 10 - 10

115 - 114 BH:bbb

 

Calzaghe-Hopkins
R1: 8-10
R2: 9-10
R3: 9-10
R4: 9-10
R5: 10-9
R6: 10-10
R7: 10-9
R8: 10-9
R9: 10-10
R10: 9-10
R11: 10-9
R12: 10-9
TOTAL:114-115

Note, though, that no way am I a B-Hop fan and I don't have a problem with people scoring the fight for Calzaghe. Close fight imo.

 

2 x 10-10 rounds, bad scorecards, next.

Judges almost never score 10-10, nevermind twice.

 

If a round is even, it should be scored even. Whether you've scored one already is irrelevant. You don't arbitrarily award points to someone because you don't want to be repetitive.

 

:deal

 

Ahem, bad scorecard cause of the even rounds?

So if they were not 10-10, 10-10 but 10-9, 9-10 instead, my scorecard would be "good"?

Different from yours, yes. Bad??? And I this is how I scored the fight the first time I saw it, so humor me if I haven't yet reached your Stanley Christodoulou judging level

You a judge by any chance? :huh

 

Judges don't score 10-10 rounds, thats a fact which most amatuers forget

There is always someone more deserving of a round.

 

Thank you.

 

Vegas judges don't tend to score even rounds. British judges often do. Personally I always like to find a winner but there's nothing wrong with scoring an even round.