erm mine 1) Muhammed Ali 2) Sugar Ray Leonard 3) Marvin Hagler 5) Joe Calzaghe 6) Floyd Mayweather 7) RJJ 8) Nigel Benn 9) Bernard Hopkins 10) Marco Antonio Barrera
Roy Jones Jr. Bernard Hopkins Floyd Mayweather Winky Wright Joe Calzaghe Shane Mosley James Toney Naseem Hamed Miguel Cotto Tito Trinidad Pernell Whitaker From the current era basiscally, not all time..
Listing Toney is just wrong. He was dodgy aka 'old school'. He can't outbox anyone half decent. Barrera is a master boxer, not bloody Toney.
I would list Cristian Mijares as number 1, but that would be unfair to the next 9, as it would make those master boxers look like amatuers and probably ruin the entire image of the sport if this logic got out. So we'll just list Mijares simply as 'God', as usual.
Toney has fantastic boxing skill and knowledge, and I don't think anyone other than you would argue that... His defense is amazing, he is a world class counterpuncher, can throw a variety of combinations, is one of the best in-fighters you'll ever see, and doesn't fight dirty. He maybe the cleanest, toughest fighter you could ever face. Virtually no one can look good against him...and I hate to break to you, but he would've beaten Calzaghe at 168... I know JC is your idol, or Dad, or BF, or something...but you are just starting to sound ridiculous.