Your top 10 P4P.............

1. Fedor Emilianenko
2a. George St Pierre
2b. Anderson Silva
4. BJ Penn
5. Lyoto Machida
6. Shogun Rua
7. Gegard Mousasi
8. Jose Aldo
9. Urijah Faber
10. Mike Brown


Brown and Faber are interchangeable

 

GSP
Silva
BJ
Fedor

I'm not very sure after that. Sometimes I put Fedor top; sometimes it might be Silva. Very hard to say. After those 4 it's up for grabs from the usual names like Mousasi, Machida and Aldo.

 

1. Fedor Emilianenko
2. George St Pierre
3. Anderson Silva
4. BJ Penn
5. Shogun Rua
6. Lyoto Machida
7. Gegard Mousasi
8. Jose Aldo
9. Mike Brown
10. Florian or Fitch

 

Something like this:

1. Fedor
2. Anderson Silva
3. Penn
4. GSP
5. Machida
6. Shogun
7. Aldo
8. Mousasi
9. Faber
10. Fitch

 

Anderson
GSP
Fedor
BJ
Machida
Aldo
Shogun
Shields
Faber
Vitor

I think the top 7 or 8 picks itself to an extent then it's just opinions

 

Not my P4P top 10....(there's nothing more illogical and anti-scientific than the P4P argument)...

But here's my current top 10..

1 - GSP
2 - BJ Penn
3 - Mousasi
4 - Shogun
5 - Machida
6 - Anderson
7 - Aldo
8 - Brown
9 - Faber
10 - Aoki


Ps: I consider Fedor as the goat of the sport...& an atg...No need to even rank him in any top 10.. even if he loses his next fight or all his other future fights...he's already a living legend....

 

GSP
A.Silva
Penn
Fedor
Shogun
Aldo
Machida
Faber
Brown
Lesnar

 

we should change the name of this stupid debate and not call it the P4P debate because in all fairness all those list are just opinions.

Why don't we call it
The Fedor's list?
He is the GOAT.

 

1. BJ - unbeatable at LW. The most dominant at his own weightclass. Can beat 95% of WW's.
2. Fedor - unbeatable at HW but lately looked vulnerable at times. Fights much bigger guys.
3. Anderson - unbeatable at 185 and looks the same at 205.
4. GSP - A dominant grinder at WW but needs to fight someone at a diff weightclass to really know.

 

I'll never understand why anyone with a half-functioning brain can put Penn above GSP.

I mean, seriously? M.R.I. Get one.

 

Chimba is a known BJ Penn nutthuggers. And not because he put Penn over GSP 'cause he can have arguments..but to put Penn before Fedor is just crazy.
Fedor is undefeated and after GSP, he is the one with the most top 10 wins.

 

Penn = More dominant in his weightclass. Have fought and has succeeded in "other" weightclasses.

For BJ p4p is not a myth. He has done it for real. Just because someone whos 25 lbs heavier in muscle beat someone.. doesnt necessarilly mean he is above that fighter p4p. Thats not how it works.

Some are talking about BJ moving down to 145 when GSP needs to move up to 185. Go figure.

Now if GSP beats Anderson which would equal BJ beating prime Hughes, then I can understand placing GSP above Penn.

 

If this is a p4p snapshot now, not 2 years ago, then Id say Fedor..But lately Fedor is not as impressive in his wins. Meanwhile BJ semi-disinterestingly destroys Diego (who gives most WW fits). Thats just pure domination right there.

BJ as of NOW is the most dominant and exciting champion in MMA. And something tells me he is about to get better.

 

Shogun above Penn???? atsch