Your top 3 at Middleweight

I'll determine after the Chavez and Martinez fight.

 

I think the first 2 are correct, the third place could go to any of these fighters: Chavez JR, Pirog and Golovkin.

 

1. Martinez
2. Golovkin
3. Geale or Chavez Jr

H2H, I'd put Golovkin at the top. He'd thrash Martinez. It'd be brutal.

 

Not a fan of Jr but he has a better resume than Daniel Geale and triple G .

1.Martinez
2.Jr
3.Geale / GGG
4.Pirog
5.Macklin
6.Sturm :yep

 

1. Martinez
2. Golovkin
3. Chavez

 

How does Jr have a better resume that Geale who beat Sturm?

 

Sturm was a hyped-protected fighter ! He lost against Macklin but the judges gave him the decision . :yep

Zbik , Rubio and Lee are better wins overall than Sebastian Sylvester (SD) and Sturm (SD) :deal

 

You can't say Zbik is a better win than Sturm since they fought and Sturm stopped him who has lee really beat?

 

Ok, Sturm is a far better win than Rubio or Lee. Agree ! The fact that Geale won this fight in Germany makes his win even bigger ! :yep

1. Martinez
2. Geale
3. Jr / GGG
4. Pirog
5. Macklin

 

1) Martinez
2) Golovkin
3) Pirog

Rest of my top ten:

4) Geale

5) Chavez/Sturm


6) The British Isles crew (Lee, Barker, Macklin, Murray)

 

That is absurd. How is the win over Zbik better than the win over Sturm? It was just as difficult for Chavez as Sturm was for Geale, and the result as controversial and divisive.. Not to mention Sturm >>>>>> Zbik as proven h2h.

Zbik is trash. Chavez struggled mightily and in some peoples' opinion got a gift over a trash fighter

Geale struggled and scraped out a win in a close fight (could have gone either way) against a vastly superior fighter to Zbik who was a legit world class titleholder, if past his sell-by.

 

I didn't mention Rubio because I don't really know much about him. But wins against two title holders has too count for something.

 

1. Martinez/Chavez winner
2. Golovkin
3. Martinez/Chavez loser

Honorable Mention: Geale

 

martinez
......................
...........
...........
golovkin
piroq