Zab Judah Hall of Fame?

talent means nothing...if you cant execute it....

David Reid was talented....
Francisco Bojado was talented beyond belief


its like the guy in baseball who can hit homeruns in practice...but not even get ahit in a game..... obviously talented....but...you see where im going

 

No

 

a lost to hatton would mean a firm no

but if he wins, he can get in there depending on the timing...the ibhof inducts 3-4 modern boxers a year...he would not make in his first year of eligibility though

 

hell no!!!!! if ur loss column is more impressive then ur win column then absolutely not..meaning that the opponents judah has lost to are way better than anyone he's ever beaten

 

No way hall of fame. Zab Judah? The Hall has to stand for something.

 

there should be like a pyramid building of the hall of fame....and the very top of the building is for the like of ali, srr, leonard, tyson, duran people like that....then there should be on the lower floors guys like gatti and hatton, very good boxers imo that deserve to be in the hall.....but not ATG......

you will only find judah in the hall by his pictures of the real hall of famers beating him in there fights.

 

no way.

 

Fail.

 

no way

 

He even doesn't Win over some big name's

 

No, just in the Hall of Shame!

 

chicken dancing hall of fame perhaps.

 

He's definitely a level or two above Gatti, p4p he would smack Gatti around like he was nothing. That doesn't mean he belongs in the HOF though. imho, he COULD have gotten there had he stayed at 140 and won some fights, but moving to 147 and taking beatings has blown it for him. Unless of course he can still get back down and make some noise. Who could beat him at 140 right now besides Pacquiao? You know Judah would murderize Hatton.

 

You can't put Reid in the same sentence with Bojado. Without that droopy eye I think Reid beats Tito and makes a HOF career for himself. It wasn't anything he did that screwed him, it was something physical that was beyond his control. By the sixth round of every fight he had to lean his head back so far to see his opponent that his chin was practically higher than his forehead.

Very sad case.

 

Zab Judah is capable of competing at welterweight as long as he gets a new trainer, even without a new trainer I give him a good shot at beating Andre Berto.