Zab Judah or Glen Johnson.... who accomplished more?

picked johnson cause his jamaican

jamaica land me love

 

Picked Johnson because I like him more and therefore is better in every way possible.

 

People have reasons to not like Judah, who doesn't like Johnson?

 

johnson had the better wins

 

Have to go with Glen.

 

Johnson has that everyday man humility . Zab acts like a spoilt child.

Which one would you vote for?

 

Its a hard pick really

Zab Judah

won 42 (KO 29) + lost 7 (KO 3) + drawn 0 = 51

Age : 35

Titles won

IBF Light Welterweight title - 5 succesfull defences
WBO Light Welterweight title - 1 Succesfull defence
WBC/WBA/IBF Welterweight titles - 1 Succesfull defence
Won IBF Light Welterweight title again but failed to defend it

Also fought for

WBA Light Welterweight title (IBF Unification)
IBF Welterweight title twice
WBA Welterweight title
WBA/WBC/IBF Welterweight titles
Currently challenging for the WBA/WBC Light Welterweight titles

Noteable wins - Witter, Ward, Spinks, Matthysse (all be it questionable)
Noteable losses - Tszyu, Spinks, Baldomir, Mayweather, Cotto, Clottey, Khan

Glen Johnson

won 51 (KO 35) + lost 18 (KO 1) + drawn 2 = 71

Age : 43

Titles won

IBF Light Heavyweight title - 1 succesfull defence
IBO Light Heavyweight title - 1 succesfull defence

Also fought for

IBF Middleweight title
IBF Super Middleweight title twice
IBF Light Heavyweight title 3 times
WBC Light Heavyweight title twice
WBC Super Middleweight title

Noteable wins : Woods, Jones, Tarver, Green
Noteable losses : Woods, Tarver, Bute, Froch, Hopkins, Ottke (Questionable) Cloud, Dawson twice (first fight was questionable)

On Paper Judah wins but when you look at the actual fights everytime judah has stepped up in competition hes lost decisevly via decision or stoppage whilst Johnson was a late bloomer and took on a lot of tough competition with his only stoppage to date being to Bernard Hopkins in his first loss 15-16 years ago.

Also factor in Johnsons performances in his losses against Dawson and Froch at such a late age in the game giving each opponent a tough fight, if only Johnson was able to put perfomances like that in earlier in his career and had chances that Judah has had by having the luxury of fighting a unified champion at the calibur of spinks.

Judahs thug/gangsta wannabe mentality backed up with his performances Vs Johnsons grit and detirmination plus his longetivity

Judah wins on Paper
Johnson wins in the ring ( pound for pound of course )

 

Judah has a greater legacy imo. Undisputed champ at welter and champ at 2 weights. Although he is a wanker he has had the better career

 

depends which way you look at it

like i stated above, Judahs resume looks far better in terms of the belts he won with the spinks rematch being his best win but Johnson carried on until the age of 43 putting up great fights each time and its a shame he had to go out the way he did (4 losses in a row : Froch, Bute, Fonfara, Groves)

Johnson should have been a 2 weight world champion in my eyes

IBF Supermiddleweight champion

Possible fights with WBA champ mitchell, WBO champ Calzaghe, WBC Champ Lucas and Charles Brewer who was wronged twice by Ottke

IBF/WBC Light heavyweight champion

If he had those fights on his resume hes overtake Judah

 

Judah accomplished more but Johnson has the better wins, if that makes any sense... Titles > opponents

 

Johnson has 18 losses and that should tell you something.

 

Griffin, Tarver, Jones, Woods, and what I thought was a close decision loss against Froch...I think that has him edge Judah, who has Spinks, Ward, Witter, and maybe Lucas Matthysse.