So, basically beating Gonzalez is the only noteable thing he did at 175? The rest of the guys you mentioned are a bunch of scrubs who's only claim to fame appears to be that the "were good enough" to fight other guys who were padding their records by beating them.
You obviously didnt read properly as Garay went on to become WBA champ, Fragomeni was a CW world champ. Sahnoune was a former WBA champ with only one loss, and Gonzalez WBO champ. Facts :deal
Fragomeni - good win. Gonzalez - decent fighter. Sahnoune and Garay - mediocre fighters who only became "world champions" thanks to the proliferation of alphabet titles. Facts.
Bute won't fight a clever technical fighter like Erdei. His best wins are Andrade and Miranda,both are warriors but not versatile.
What's going on bailey? OH nevermind, I can see you are busy praising/defending some more euro bums LOL. I know this will take a while so I will talk to you later. Peace
Not facts at all and completely wrong as Garay has a win over Braehmer the current WBO LHW champ, only lost to Campillo the then WBA champ who holds a win over current champ Shumenov and was considered unlucky by many in a return. Sahnoune became a world champ by beating 2 weight champ Girard who had wins over B Mitchell, Siaca and Lou Del Valle. Dosent sound like the proliferation of alphabet titles with all those world class names mentioned
If you want to considerably lower the bar of what it means to be world class, then yeah, I suppose. Seriously - the fact you can call Girard a two-weight world champion should be enough to convince anyone we have too many titles. Garay and Sahnoune are mediocre at best. No matter how many guys they fought who lost to some other guy, who beat someone else - they're not very good fighters.
Those guys on Erdei's resume is who I'm refering to. This guy should have fought tough guys when he had the chance in his prime and now we will never know how good he was. He waited too long and he had the chance to make it to where no one could deny how good he was. If he proves me wrong and gets a win against someone I would favor to beat him then I'll be impressed.
Girard was a 2 weight world champ. He beat B Mitchell, the then undefeated WBA champ who had beaten F Liles, rated the #1 SMW. Girard also beat Siaca who later became a WBA champ. Del Valle was a former world champ who knocked Jones Jnr down. I produced facts about all the fighters to back the claims
What dont you grasp :huh. Read below Campillo then WBA champ and Cloud IBF champ pulled out of unifications against Erdei. He was in a contract that limited him. But beat Gonzalez coming off his biggest win and Fragomeni a world champ at a weight above
Girard is nothing but mediocre. Beating some other mediocre fighters doesn't somehow make him a world-beater. I'm not sure what Del Valle scoring a flash-knockdown against RJJ in the midst of being totally out-classed proves either. No amount of this kind of logic can convince anyone Erdei has a good resume.
Girard beat the guy that KOd the Ring rated #1 SMW. Erdei has a better resume than Dawson who beat Adamek who had done little as a LHW, beat 14 fight loser Johnson, who in turn had lost to Gonzalez who Erdei beat, Johnson also owns a win and loss over Tarver, compared to Erdeis 11 defences and being a 2 weight champ
This aint highlander . You don't gain the other guys defeats because you beat him. None of those win on Erdei's resume mean ****. I find it extremely funny that you have the nerve to call other fighters hype jobs and defend Erdei and his bum resume. You even got the nerve to talk about Chad Dawson in the face of this guys resume :stfu. How shameful that you have no shame. You need to sit down and reflect on your points against other fighters and apply it to this guy inparticular:ass. You have to be the hugest double standard having hypocritical poster on this site:deal. :smh
So this proves you cant defend Dawsons resume as you know you will get badly pwned. No its not highlander but it shows levels. Erdei beat the WBO champ (11 defences) a future WBA champ, a European champ and went up to beat a world champ in a higher division. I notice you fail to acknowledge how Campillo and CLOUD backed out of fighting Erdei