Fine. One " Bad " list. This is the best division, Hard to sort out, Therefore it might be the worst list :conf. My other lists looked good mostly.
1. Andre Ward 2. Lucian Bute 3. Carl Froch 4. Mikkel Kessler 5. Andre Dirrell 6. Glen Johnson 7. Sakio Bika 8. Robert Stieglitz 9. George Groves 10. Brian Magee Next, in no particular order: Thomas Oosthuizen, Librado Andrade, James DeGale, Kelly Pavlik, Dimitri Sartison. For the top 3, I don't care who is #1 or #3, they all have good arguments to be on top right now. But that will change after the Super 6.
Dirrell and Johnson over Stieglitz @168? :think... Who is Dirrell's best win? Johnson's best win is Allan Green at SMW and neither has won a title @168.. I think that both would be able to beat Stieglitz, but in terms of resume and accomplishments, Stieglitz is a tier above Johnson and Dirrell..
1. Froch 2. Ward 3. Kessler 4. Bute 5. Johnson 6. Groves 7. Degale 8. Bika 9. Oosthuizen 10. Eubank Jr :happy
Bute too low. Froch way too high. Ward ok I guess, 1-2. Groves and Degale :rofl. Bika is ok, And Oosthuizen is ok. Eubank Jr WTF???
Ward Kessler Bute Froch Dirrell Johnson Stieglitz Abraham Pavlik Bika Oosthuizen Sartison Groves Balzsay Kashtanov :think How can anyone rank Froch ahead of Kessler? Degale lost to Groves and nearly lost to that polish nobody who has never beaten a top150 smw, Magee has never beaten a top150 as well, i don't think anyone had Rodriguez winning his last fight against some nobody besides those strange judges, his *win* over Pryor was dubious as well at the very best so he has basically never beaten anyone too i fail to understand how those guys even deserve a mention..
Switch Bute and Froch and I could agree. Actually if your Supermiddleweight rating is based on achievement, It should go like : Ward Froch Kessler Bute If it's based on abilities : Ward/Bute Kessler/Froch.
Whatever... Chavez Jr, Pryor Jr, and Eubank Jr are not there fathers, Sure they all have potential, Let them prove it, Not their fathers.
Yep just based on achievements trying to be fair to anyone about what they have done. thats like those ranking are done. head2head everyone can have his opinion, its more interesting but controversial and its barely possible to find some consensus. I still don't see how Froch can be ranked above Kessler though
now wait.... has Bute beaten anyone???? has he even fought outside of his backyard? dont put him on the top of your list. top 5 is being kind.
Ward will be one after he beats froch. I would say maybe froch will shut up but im sure he will have his list of excuses ready.
at the time super 6 was made... i think 5 of 6 would beat Bute. now as the best fought each other, Bute somehow goes to the top having faced no one near the top. come on