Then you proceed to claim that some of his wins are losses. That's not looking at his record then now is it.
You forgot Bob Fitzsimmons Harry Greb Mickey Walker Dick Tiger Bernard Hopkins awwww, that is a long list. What Donaire had done is far more historical that Canelo
Like I said before, with the exception of Mickey Walker, those are middleweights who became light heavyweights. Canelo was a junior middleweight who became a light heavyweight champ.
H2H i will fancy Donaire to be Top 10 Bantamweight and Flyweight. I do not think Canelo is Top 10 in any of MW or LHW.
None of those guys were ever A-level fighters. Consider that A levels are MAB, Morales, JMM, Naseem, Kevin Kelly (barely, maybe an A-), Rigo, Donaire, Inoue, Nelson, Fenech, Loma. Walters is probably B-C, Frampton is a B+ on his best day.
So you don't view those guys as A-level fighters. That's fine. As long as there are very few A-level wins across all of current boxers' accolades... In which case his resume still stacks up just as great so doesn't even matter.
You're right, there are very few A-level wins. Which is why Canelo only has 1 A-level win, GGG. Unless you're going to argue that Darchinyan is on equal level ability-wise to GGG. I'm not sure who is greater as of now, I thought it was Donaire, but Canelo has a decent argument.