Would you rate juanma higher than tito if..........

Katsidis and Diaz I could see, but Nonito and Vic theyre not even a match.atsch

 

please explain

 

If he does that it'll be similar to the run tito had when he beat DLH, reid, vargas and joppy... add chris john to the list and i'll put him right up there with tito and if he goes on and wins a title at 130 and 135 then i'll put him at the #1 puertorrican fighter of all time but lets wait and see that's a lot of ifs and it looks like dreaming right now

:hat

 

vic and donaire would have to move up, id give the power advantage to juanma easy.

they are not the purest of boxers either. you make it sound like he has no chance

 

NAZ said he would turn his fists into bats......

 

I dont see Vic doing anything against the superior boxer in Juanma.You have an arguement with Nonito however but again I see Juanma Koing him. A Chris John victory however on top of the other three would definitely elevate him above Tito and I'm a huge Tito fan. But it would mean that Juanma has won really every major fight in his career. Tito did not do that.

 

To call him a fraud like a Margarito is completely baseless though.

 

It's hard to say because Tito beat alot of very good fighters that had Tito not been around they could of probably been greats themselves. For example like Yory Boy Campas who was 56-0 and dropped Tito before being ko'd himself. Fernando Vargas, David Reid, and alot of very good fighters. Oscar didn't lose to Tito and that's where I think Tito's stock falls for me. That was supposed to be his most important win and he got exposed, as did Oscar, but Tito looked the loser in that fight.

I think John is very underrated in his division and even in his loss to Marquez, because Marquez did get robbed, John held his own in that fight and made it a close fight. I think John has what it takes to upset Caballero, Gamboa, and Juanma, but if Juanma is able to beat those guys, I would have him on par with Tito. If Juanma is able to beat a Donaire, afterwards, I'd definitely have him higher than Tito.

 

Yes, but it won't happen.

 

Great post with excellent points:good

 

I'll go with no.

 

Really, okay newbie. What more would he have to do to at least be as high as Cotto??

 

Well, Gamboa still needs to really prove himself against top opposition, at this point he's still developing and climbing up the ranks. But if he beats Marquez and Caballero, I'll put him up there with Cotto but behind Tito, so he'll need a little more to surpass Tito status.

 

How is it baseless? Trinidad was caught doing the same thing as Margarito.

 

im puerto rican tito is my favorite of all time followed by cotto,juanma can pass cotto but not with those 3 wins he needs much more then that to pass cotto,to pass tito is another level,tito neverrr lost at welterweight for yrs titos resume is way up there,when its all said and dun i thnk hell pass cotto but not tito