Liston, he'd be able to take Holyfield's punches in a brawl and hurt Holyfield himself, and they would brawl. I like Liston to jab Holy whilst not exchanging to win rounds and set up his shots to hurt Holyfield, he'd eat a few counters though. Great fight, Liston UD12. But there's an issue, you've done this twice before. https://www.boxingforum24.com/threads/sonny-liston-vs-evander-holyfield-primes.631403/ https://www.boxingforum24.com/threa...me-liston-does-liston-get-torn-up-too.595988/
Holyfield's darting style confuses and frustrates the hell out of Liston. In the 9th round Holy hurts him with a tripled up hook and Liston holds until the end of the fight. Holy unanimous decision. Liston was a great fighter, I just don't place him as high as Holy in the pantheon (and yeah I know how amazing he was in the fifties).
I wonder who would be stronger Williams or Holyfield? Since it took a few rounds for Liston to push him back, Holy had a bit of strength more so moving/pushing as opposed to power in his shots. Liston said he had doubts going in, but gained confidence in victory over Williams. I can see that smirk on Holy's face telling Liston this aint gonna be easy. Holy had excellent lateral movement for defense as his muscular upper body didn't allow a style of ducking, bobbing or weaving. He IMO would use his feet-work & lateral movement to cause Liston to reset. Over & over. Only in mid-rounds does Liston catch him which ruins Holy's discipline, aww shux...a fight done broke out! I think it is a marvelous back n forth scrap where Holy gets the nod on 2 scorecards, one a draw via MD.
Let me go into post fight mode. Well, BCS8 won, I take nothing away from him. But my keyboard kept getting stuck on the (H) Key, so I had to retype giving BCS8 that extra second, but I'm not making excuses. And when my browser shut down, I had to reboot my pc, but I aint taking nothing away from BCS8, No excuses. But when I spilled my coffee, heck I couldn't hit enter right then...had to find the Clorox wipes, not the regular kind which took additional time. But like I said....no excuses...
Sonny Liston executes Evander and I don't think it'd take too long to do it, inside 5. This ain't a 42 year old Foreman who hurt Holyfield.
I think it’s conceivable that Holyfield fights a really smart fight and stays away and outpoints him. I think an ATG brawl is more likely, one where Holyfield is outgunned but not stopped. Liston UD
There are 2 strikes against Holyfield here. 1 - In 1991 he was barely 210lbs with a tiny waist & that's not a good combo against a monster like Liston. 2 - At this stage of his career he was drawn into a bar room brawl too easily, which is a recipe for disaster here, the result would be a UD or late stoppage for Liston.
To be fair, he had much faster hands than Liston, was more accurate with his punches and tossed better combinations.