..and I have Margo ranked above Williams.. Read my first post why.. Cotto was #1, Margo beat Cotto.. 01. Margarito 02. Cotto 03. Williams
That's not the way it goes as far as rankings are concerned. A fighter's resume plays the most important role here. Bigger names and where were they ranked at that time. If the resume is more or less even, then head to head comes into play My list: 1. Margarito (based on quality of opposition) 2. Williams (a very close second) 3. Cotto (a very close third, put him below Williams cause he's coming off a big defeat, losing his title) 4. Clottey 5. Mosley 6. Quintana 7. Berto 8. Cintron 9. Judah 10. Ouali
Yes Williams has a win over Margo but Margarito still has beaten the better comp at 147 with wins over Cotto,Cintron,Clottey,SixHeads.
I commented because I feel like someone who ranks Cotto above Williams is not being objective, and ranking based on who they like, as opposed to who they think is better. Period. I never said anything about "fave"... That was actually YOUR comment I quoted that from. Maybe you should scroll back and read. If you actually read the post instead of looking for a chance to hurl an insult you might actually comprehend what I am saying.
I assume you meant that that's not the way it goes as far as your own personal rankings are concerned. Other people may favour a completely different approach and presumably you are not claiming to be somekind of authority that should be deferred to.
I thought about putting Karass in my top ten too I'm glad someone else did I might change my number 10 pick now.
No need for the attitude. Of course I just stated my opinion. From what I understand reading articles and listening to boxing writers, that is more or less how it goes as far as rankings are concerned. So far I haven't bumped into an article, boxing website etc. that has Williams above Margarito. I guess they have a reason to place Margo above Paul and I assume they rate fighters the way I described, and I agree with their logic. Well I wrote about the way I rank fighters, how do you rank them and who do you have at #1?
Dude....give me a break. All of a sudden you are sensitive to insults? **** OFF MAN...:rofl You're not even making any sense. YOU BROUGHT UP FAVES DIP****. You can't say you never said anything abuot faves. Makes you an outright, and blatant LIAR. That's funny that you think anyone who posts Cotto ISN'T being objective. How far down does the #1 guys fall after a loss? How far did Williams move down the rankings when he lost to Quintana? And remember, Quintana was a lower top ten (if that...someone posted #19) WW. You are ignoring ALL of that and acting likle a friggin baby.