I think if you are in the top 100, then you are an All Time Great. So, if you count the original 8 weight divisions, then top 15 being All Time...
I love both these fighters. But I think Holyfield batters Norton to a referee's stoppage.
Some great lists here. Am I just being a casual by noting the lack of love for Ike Quartey (I see @Flo_Raden mentioned him)? Surely he should...
A lot of the replies to this thread seem to more correctly answer the question, 'What if X fighter was a bigger puncher'? Because, for example, if...
Note: "anywhere up to 168lb", not "Super-Middleweight." (Weigh in up to 168lb, same day. Approx. 50% resume, 50% H2H). 1. Greb 2. Fitzsimmons 3....
On my All-Time p4p list I have Olivares at #38 and Canelo #120. I'd say that's pretty accurate.
Two things: A. I probably overrate my favourites, now I think about it. B. I obviously like a fighter with a good story. 1. Sonny Liston 2....
Not dominant, but right up there with the best of them.
I actually have Tyson at 71 myself, so I can't really complain at 72! 71. Tyson 72. LaMotta 73. Hopkins etc...
Witherspoon by late stoppage.
Maybe something like this: 1. Bowe (41-0-0) 2. Fury (34-0-1) 3. W Klitschko (64-5) 4. V Klitschko (44-1) 5. Johnson (53-11-8) 6. Dempsey (53-6-8)...
Just about, for me. Something like this: 8. Tyson 9. Frazier 10. Usyk 11. Bowe
I have Ali a clear number 1. But then, I factor H2H more than most. I think there are very few who can beat Ali. I have Louis at a precarious...
25 to 30 seems about right to me. Great fighter.
Lewis by ref stoppage or KO in the first half of the fight.