130 lb. All-time tournament

Being a warrior doesn't mean you win fights. Floyd is head and shoulders over everyone on this list. The ring already stated that Floyd is the most dominate fighter at 130.

 

Why have you got gatti in this tournament but no nelson?

 

I'm with you on this one

 

another vote for Chavez

 

Pac is not undefeated at that weight.

 

camacho was too fast for any of them including floyd

 

PBF will win the tournament hands down.

 

floyd would kick all their asses...no doubt about it. of all those has beens floyd is the only 5 division champ..not chavez, arguello, or nelson could do what floyd did. history will judge floyd as the only 130 fighter to move up and win titles in 4 other divisions.

 

Excellent point.

I like his scenerio, though.

 

comes down to arguello - floyd. jcc was much better at 135.

 

Maybe its insane but for some reason I feel a well trained motivated Hector Camacho had the stuff at that weight to beat all those guys. Too bad Macho was an idiot. I really mean it, he had the skills just cant rely on his mental state. But at 130 when he was yound he was no joke.

 

There could be quite a few better choices in there, but I'd still pick the same man to win, and that would likely be Floyd Mayweather. Guys like Azumah Nelson and Chavez would give him a rumble though, and are capable of pulling it off. I'd favor Chavez at 135 in fact.

Based on styles, I'd have to favor Floyd over Arguello, though that's not to say he's a greater fighter.

 

Depends on how the brackets/styles are.

If they fought as you listen them there?

Arguello KO 9 Pac-mAN
Chavez WIDE UD Camacho
Mayweather SD DLH
Mitchell KO 11 Gatti

JCC SD Arguello (THAT MAN NEVER didn't get the benefit of the doubt on scorecards)
Mayweather UD Mitchell

Finals
JCC SD Mayweather

 

Ones I disagree with:

I don't think, at 130, the fight between Chavez and Camacho would be nearly the same, though Chavez may very well win. It wouldn't be a Wide UD, in fact Camacho would probably take plenty of early rounds.

Mayweather would dominate the green DLH that fought at 130.

 

pacquiao would win