An accurate P4P list

1. Floyd
2. Ward (he got the decision, even tho I disagree, and it's settled at the weekend
3. Kovalev (see above)
4. GGG
5. Loma
6. Pacquiao
7. Crawford
8. Canelo
9. M Garcia
10. Spence

 

Have included Floyd as I feel Pacquiao warrants a place and he beat him comfortably in their fight. Also, Floyd has shown that long delays between fights don't matter to him (wouldnt be a factor in his latest exhibition fight even if it did)

 

Better than Gimp C's list, but not as accurate as mine.

 

M Garcia is too inactive but pretty cool mate ...obviously apart from Floyd tho

 

Cheers mate Floyd is a tricky one as I feel Pacquiao is still p4p material, and Floyd bested him

 

Get rid of GGG and you have a good list.

 

Yours is 10000000 light years worse than both.

 

still waiting for a P4P list where the same criteria is applied to the fighters, wouldnt care how outrageous the names on it would be ))))

 

Outside of Floyd being on there not bad at all.

 

For some reason as soon as I saw the thread title I knew I would be reading a hopelessly inaccurate P4P list. Funny how that works.

 

Exactly the reason I don't indulge in it myself, although I do enjoy reading other people's opinions. It's far too subjective and it becomes a clusterf*ck of mental gymnastics. Judging by natural size and ability in larger weight classes I believe Pac is head and shoulders above every other recent fighter, by resume it would easily be Floyd (or probably Ward if you consider Floyd retired) but ignoring those and just using the eye test then Chocolatito, Loma and Crawford all stake a claim.
How does one accurately compare Pac's ability to compete with guys 5-6 weight classes above his natural weight with Crawford's ability to absolutely dismantle a guy the same size as him? It's impossible to do so objectively.

 

Mayweather did NOT beat Pacquaio !! That debacle was a disgrace & qas indeed one of boxings biggest embarassments. One fighter caight BLATANTLY CHEATING & the State Commission VAINLY trying to cover his ass
Boxing last all credibility on May 1 & 2 2015

 

You putting a blatant cheat @ #1 made a laughing stock of yours

 

GGG bumluvkin tomato can kicker , no way.

TBE is he retired or not? wtf.

Pac p4p he wont fight thurman spence or crawford. he is outta there , retired on the job. lol

 

Stop it!