Archie won the title from Maxim at 38 which is very old now for a fighter but truly ancient then. Consider the life expectancy for a black man in the USA in 1950 was 59. In 2025 it's only 69. That equates to the age Archie would be winning the title now to 48. Otherwise, your description of Dwight is right on. And, consider he didn't turn pro until age 25 and had no amateur background. So both guys were freaks. All said, we have to wager that a la M Spinks in a memorable fight the prime Archie tops Dwight but not by domination.