This is the only logical answer , where are the nuthuggers who voted for Joe? Let them please explain?
Roy beat Toney and Bernard when they were young and still had plenty left in the tank. Calzaghe just beat an old roy. Case closed. Roy is still #1.
Seems to an obseesion talking about primes since Calzaghe schooled Jones. the best is not judged on a 15-20 fight period in the middle of theirs careers its judged on the whole career loses and twilight included.People keepsaying a prime jones would easily beat Calzaghe well maybe maybe not but why is that so important,I think Calzaghe age 16 would beat Jones at the same age,who cares lol. Ray Robinson is regarded by most as the greatest ever because of his consistency over his 'WHOLE' career.Im sure other boxers like maybe Sugar Ray Leonard might have been able to beat Robinson at his prime,it doesn't matter.
Calzaghe/Hopkins Jones Toney Big shitstain on the 3 American boxers is they never fought a big fight abroad outside the comfort zone against a big fighter in his home.
Fat **** Toney should not outrank Calzaghe...sure, he's never been knocked out, but he lost bad a number of times...Joe is still undefeated last I checked.