floyd beat shane at 147 no catchweight for a real title (which he didnt even want) manny beat tony(who shane ko'd)-catch weight,vacant title
mosley would have been an obvious better win, but he looked way old and shot in there. Margo had almost a 20lb advantage and in great shape so that evens things out. I'd say Floyd's win is better overall but not by much.
Floyd fought an old Mosley who gassed after the 3rd round and suspiciously backed off after having Floyd on ***** Street. Pac beat a guy 17 pounds heavier who was in the best shape of his life. Pac. :deal
Who cares about titles. Shane beat the ****ing bejesus out of Margarito, so I would say Floyd's schooling of Shane was a better win, though Pacquiao may have won his fight in more impressive fashion.
Well the more impressive win was Pacquiao as he rearranged Margarito's face for 12 rounds. But the better win resume wise would be Floyd beating Shane. I still think Pac's win over Cotto is greater then Floyd's over Shane though.
That's debatable in and of itself. But thanks for the objective post. ESB has short-term memory. The poll results are quite humorous.
pac vs margo for sure!........shane and floyd were almost the same size....and also based on perfrmance, pac wins!