Maybe he isn't but maybe he is and that's just how damn low boxing has sunk but correct me if I'm wrong. The fellow got dominated by Andre Ward? Lost to Mr "Nothing Special" Mikael Kessler? Would lose to ancient Bernard Hopkins if given the opportunity? Got a gift stoppage in a fight that he was losing vs some unknown George Groves? Only recieved a MD VS a 2011 version of Glen Johnson? And won by SD vs Andre Dirrel? Now I'm not saying that he shouldn't legitimately be on P4P lists but if he legitimately belongs there then Holy Moly boxing has sunk to new depths. I do think that boxing really has sunk to new depths but could it be that these Carl Froch appearances on P4P lists have less to do with boxing having sunk to new depths and more to do with the fact that the UK has an abnormal ammount of ******ed boxing enthusiast that worship their Ricky Hattons, Amir Khans and Carl Frochs?
Not many active fights have better wins than Pascal, Taylor, Dirrell, Abraham, Kessler, Johnson, Bute, and Groves. I doubt there is 10 active boxers with better resumes in recent years.
He's there based on who he has beaten. Sure he was dominated by Ward but then there are boxers in the top 10 who have been dominated by Mayweather too.