Cazaghe better than Floyd?

Thank you. I should have summed it up that way

 

Lets see the whole thing from perspective:

Hopkins was Ring LHW champion at the time, one division up hill to Calzaghe.

Marquez was Ring champ 2 divisions below Floyd and Floyd cheated him on the scale.

True that Jones was like 5 years from his best ... but DLH was just at the edge.
In recent achievements Jones win over Trinidad might be just slightly worse than DLH's over Mayorga.

 

You mean that Baldomir had more than 0% chances of out boxing FLoyd?
:rofl

 

Shut the **** up troll. You've been on this PBF hating road for years now. You've always picked against him and he has continued to prove your hating ass wrong. Give it a rest.

 

I cant see any prove Floyd's record is better than Calzaghe ... thats all.

 

So if Floyd beats Shane and dominates are you going to start some **** about how Shane had zero chance and the only reason he was champ was because he exposed Margacheato?

 

Since you wanna use that logic DLH was JMW champion(one division above Floyd) so he would be you're equal to Hopkins in this arguement NOT Jones.

 

You right ... putting Pudwill in front of Baldomir was shot below the belt line.
I sincerelly appologize Baldormir fans and here is the real h2h comparison

Cindirella man vs Cindirella man:

Manfredo jr - Baldomir

 

Calzaghe does not have a stronger resume.

 

DLH was't Ring champion also Hopkins is still top 10 p4p same as Marquez,
.... so no: Jones - DLH, Marquez - Hopkins is the proper comparison.

 

Floyd can lose that damn match and still be graded a better ATG than JC

 

I totally agree but I cant see that Floyd has stronger either,
so assuming they have even, Calzaghe's overall avievemnts:
the longevity, dominance and pure 48-0 may be > than Floyds.

 

dlh was much more formidable the jones was. jones was done after the third tarver fight. why do you think they put him in with guys like prince badi and hanshaw. and Trinidad was 4 wieght classes removed from his original weight, 147. while mayorga had already had 3 fights at 154 and even won a belt before fighting dlh. so the mayorga victory was far more relevant.

as for your marquez and hopkins reference. well you can easily look at that and say the marquez was simply a tune-up fight mayweather as he needed a an easy victory for his comeback from his layoff. while the hopkins fight for calzaghe was his legacy fight. you cant even compare the two. unless you want to say that calzaghe's best victory is on the level of a tune up fight for mayweather, which only proof the difference in their respective resumes

 

No then I will apologize all Floyd's fans and I will say that
Floyd clearly have better resume than Joe :deal

 

Haha. Im no Baldo fan but i'd say thats a more accurate comparison. manfredo is still no belt holder though.